Pragmatism: concepts
- Pragmatism is an educational philosophy that developed in America. The American way of life shows in it.
- Progressive educational philosophers also called it utilitarianism and instrumentalism.
- Its main exponents are James, Peirce, John Dewey and Kilpatrick.
- The word "pragmatism" comes from the Greek word "pragma". Pragma means work done; "ism" means a doctrine. So it is a doctrine about work - thinking about what result comes from doing the work. Pragma also has the meanings activity, product, order, sincerity and encounter.
Metaphysics: reality is only a process. Change goes on all the time; change is the ultimate reality. Reality is not fixed; it is still in the making and is not eternal. Pragmatists have a far-sighted social outlook. They believe in God to some extent - a person believes in God for his own needs. So they said needs are ultimate. The results of activity are what matter. There are no eternal spiritual values; values change with time. What is seen physically, socially and biologically is reality. Human experiences are the centres of reality.
Epistemology: problems are the spurs to the search for truth. Truths change to suit a changing society; there is no ultimate truth. Knowledge is truth. Only knowledge gained through human experience is true knowledge. Everything in the universe - idea or matter - is always in motion. Reality is not a product; it is a process. They believed in practical knowledge. They held that man gains knowledge by interacting with the surroundings around him. They saw knowledge and truth as one idea.
Axiology: values were created by man. They arise from time, context, place and circumstances. Man is a member of society; his actions in his surroundings bring good and bad results. Values change with place, time and circumstances. "Value" and "truth" are built in the course of experience. Setting aside the view "values for their own sake", their outlook is that values exist to meet human needs.
Pragmatism: educational implications
- Aims of education: helping children lead a successful life in changing surroundings; fitting in with changing conditions and building the power to solve the problems of society; giving the education needed to become members of modern society; building social efficiency; all-round development.
- John Dewey's five new values: efficiency, scientific awareness, sociability, self-awareness, and aesthetic-economic taste. He said these should be built in pupils.
- Curriculum: it should suit needs and let pupils gain knowledge through experiences. Importance to subjects such as hygiene, physiology, home science, social studies, history, geography and agriculture.
Principles of the curriculum (6):
| No. | Principle |
|---|---|
| 1 | Utility |
| 2 | Natural interests |
| 3 | The learner's previous experiences |
| 4 | Activity |
| 5 | Flexibility |
| 6 | Integration (coordination) |
Pragmatism: teaching, discipline and teacher
- Teaching methods: pragmatists turned away from traditional knowledge, book knowledge, ready-made knowledge and passive learning. They said there is no need to follow useless traditional teaching methods. They followed learning by doing and the project method; they held that these increase teaching skill.
- The teaching method they stressed most is the experimental method. Young children have great curiosity to observe and investigate. Their curiosity to investigate is satisfied by learning through doing things themselves. They held that knowledge gained in this way is true knowledge.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
Project method was proposed by
- (1)Kilpatric
- (2)Dalton
- (3)Morison
- (4)Harlak
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (1) Kilpatric
The question asks who proposed the project method of teaching.
The project method was proposed by William Heard Kilpatrick in his 1918 essay 'The Project Method'. He was a follower of John Dewey, and the method rests on 'learning by doing'. Students choose a real-life problem, plan it, carry it out and evaluate it themselves. So the answer is option (1), Kilpatrick.
The 'Dalton Plan' (2) is an individualised teaching plan by Helen Parkhurst; Dalton is the name of the town where it was first tried. Morrison (3) is known for the unit plan. Harlak (4) is not a name linked with the project method.
Remember: Project method – Kilpatrick (Dewey's follower) – learning by doing.
- Discipline: freedom with control; social discipline is the right discipline. When group activities towards set goals are arranged in an atmosphere of freedom, cheerfulness and joy, and children work and play together, they develop self-discipline. They develop self-confidence, cooperation, compassion, friendliness, the habit of working independently and initiative in new tasks.
- Teacher: the teacher has the most important role in the educational process. He should be a companion and guide to the pupil, and the one who gives the pupil the motivation to learn tasks using his own intelligence. He should build self-discipline in pupils. He should respect the pupil's individuality. He should gain wide scientific knowledge for a complete understanding of society and the individual. He should keep good relations with the pupil and deal with him kindly. Building social efficiency is the responsibility of the teacher as guide.
- Pupil: only when learning goes on in a free atmosphere that follows the pupil's interests, tastes, habits, needs and mental make-up do self-discipline and self-confidence develop.
Exam focus: Pragmatism = born in America; pragma (Greek) = work done; change is the ultimate reality; no ultimate truth; values are man-made, for needs; teaching = learning by doing, the project method, above all the experimental method; social discipline. Exponents: John Dewey, Kilpatrick, James, Peirce.
Memory code: "Pragma = work, result, change" - whatever works is true. The 6 curriculum principles "UNPAFI": Utility, Natural interests, Previous experiences, Activity, Flexibility, Integration. "DKJP": Dewey, Kilpatrick, James, Peirce.