Realism: concepts
- The goal of realism is to build the skills needed to live successfully in society, to make a person ready for life and to achieve complete development. Realists believe that only education gained by oneself is lasting.
- Metaphysics: the material world alone is real. They turned away from particulars. They opposed the idealist claim "I think, therefore I am". They trusted only knowledge from experience gained through the senses. Their idea is that the ultimate truth is the material world.
- Epistemology: sense experiences are the royal roads to real knowledge. They gave more importance to knowledge from experience. They held that the experimental knowledge of science can be gained through sense experiences.
- Axiology: there are no universal ultimate values. They accepted natural morality and natural aesthetics; they did not accept traditional morality. They believed that freedom, humanity and cultural values are the roots of value-based education. Realism saw man as great. Man can set his own goal. Values, principles and rules should serve man's happy living. Their thinking was "Let us enjoy beauty, not violence".
Realism: educational implications
- Aims of education: (1) preparing for life (2) giving education suited to present social needs (3) the development of the child (4) not making pupils scholars, but making them able to carry out the activities of the world properly (5) controlling the surroundings is not a matter for education.
- Curriculum: it should be decided keeping in view social needs and experimentation; individual needs are not taken into account. Fixed ideals have no place. The curriculum should build the skills needed to live successfully in society. Vocational education gets a large place; literature and the fine arts were not given a prominent place.
- Teaching method: (1) the oral method, expression in words (2) from the known to the unknown (3) they encouraged the essay method (4) they encouraged teaching with the help of experiments, field trips and teaching aids.
- Teacher: he should give knowledge without depending on the pupil's likes and dislikes; he should suggest suitable programmes and activities to pupils.
- Pupil: scolding pupils and imposing outer discipline is the limit; punishment should not go beyond that. Good work can be encouraged with rewards. If the needed changes are made in the pupil's behaviour, he can live comfortably and happily in his surroundings.
Existentialism: concepts
- Existentialism = existence + doctrine. Existence means being, or to exist. The doctrine about existence is existentialism.
- It is a philosophical theory that came as a reaction against idealism. Existentialism crowns the uniqueness of what exists.
- The man who laid strong foundations for existentialism in modern times is the Danish philosopher Kierkegaard. He gave his ideas a definite shape in the book "Either/Or", written in 1843.
Basic concepts:
- Uniqueness of the individual: every person is unique; there is no other person in the world like any one person. There is no such thing as an "ordinary person". Each person's nature keeps changing according to the circumstances around him.
- Against idealism, their argument is "existence comes before essence". If there is no man, there is no general essence called manhood.
- Because man cannot live in lawless, savage conditions, he lives in society freely and by rules.
- Man is the maker of culture.
- Because existence comes before essence, the uniqueness of the individual is basic. So another basic feature of existentialism is that subjectivity is truth.
- Man has to make decisions about his life every day. This is the freedom of choice that he has by nature. This freedom of choice makes man independent; it gives a real form to the person's existence.
- Their idea is that uniqueness is reality. Existentialism does not accept generalised, certain knowledge.
Existentialism: educational implications
The existentialist idea of education is "Education is the experience of existence".
- Aims of education: (1) every person is unique, people differ, no two are equal; shaping each person as one with unique powers and abilities (2) each person should be a declaration of existence; existence is reality, not essence (3) respecting and building each person's freedom of choice (4) shaping the person so that he does not give in to the mental pressures, such as fear, dread and anxiety, that are bound to come with freedom of choice.
- Curriculum: they accept any curriculum that brings together all sides of the pupil. They do not accept making education problem-centred or vocational. There should be supports that build free choice, creativity, moral decisions and an aesthetic outlook. The humanities and the fine arts get more importance than science and technology.
- Teaching methods: because the basic idea is the uniqueness of the individual, they completely reject teacher-centred and subject-centred curricula. The phenomenological method is the attempt to understand a phenomenon in the light of the person's direct experiences of it, without cause-and-effect explanations. Many existentialists used it, but each applied it in his own way.
- Main teaching methods: the Socratic method, the individual teaching method, the non-formal teaching method, the discussion method, the creative teaching method, the inductive-deductive method, the developmental project teaching method, the inner (introspective) teaching method.
- Teacher: a director and a coordinator. There is no relationship of forcing knowledge on the pupil; there is a moral, free relationship. The teacher's role is to help pupils come out of the fears and anxieties they are bound to face, without harming the pupil's individuality.
- Discipline: not outer discipline; it builds inner discipline in the form of the person's moral responsibility.
| Point | Realism | Existentialism |
|---|---|---|
| Reality | The material world alone is true | Existence is reality; existence comes before essence |
| Knowledge | Sense experiences = royal roads | Does not accept generalised knowledge; uniqueness is reality |
| Curriculum | Social needs; vocational education gets a large place | The humanities and fine arts; not vocation-centred |
| Methods | From the known to the unknown, experiments, field trips | Socratic method, individual teaching, phenomenological method |
| Discipline | Limited outer discipline, rewards | Inner discipline as moral responsibility |
Exam focus: Realism = the material world alone is true; sense experiences are the royal roads to knowledge; opposed the claim "I think, therefore I am"; from the known to the unknown. Existentialism = existence comes before essence; uniqueness of the individual, freedom of choice; Kierkegaard (Danish), "Either/Or" (1843); rejects teacher-centred and subject-centred curricula.
Memory code: "R-M-S" - Realism = Material world + Senses. Existentialism "UFE": Uniqueness, Freedom of choice, Existence before essence. "Kierkegaard 1843 = Either/Or?" - choosing is existence.