Naturalism: concepts
- Educational philosophers such as J. J. Rousseau, Auguste Comte, Pestalozzi and Herbert Spencer spread naturalism.
- Naturalism is the complete opposite of idealism. While idealism gives importance to spiritual ideas such as the soul, the mind, ideas and the Supreme Being, naturalists gave importance to matter and nature.
- Matter comes only from matter; matter cannot come from nothing. What we see naturally around us is the real world. The whole universe is a gift of nature; everything is born from the lap of nature. Naturalists saw nature as the ultimate truth.
- Nature runs by its own self-made laws. Man is a part of nature and was born from nature. Man's duty is to act in keeping with the laws of nature. At birth every person is a pure, innocent being. Man's ideas and thoughts stay within the bounds of the physical world.
Metaphysics: nature is self-existent. Everything is born from the lap of nature and returns to it. So nature is the ultimate reality. Naturalists raised the slogans "Let us go back to nature" and "Let us break the chains of society". They did not see the mind, the body or man as separate from the physical world. The mind exists because of the brain; the brain is matter. In their philosophy there is no place for an imagined other world such as the soul, the Supreme Being, God, heaven or hell. Their argument was that the brain is not separate from the body; like other matter, it too goes back into nature - that is the law of nature.
Epistemology: the slogan "Return to nature" is theirs. They look at everything from a scientific point of view. Scientific knowledge is the best. "The senses are the gateways of knowledge" - only what is gained through the senses is true knowledge. They believed there is no knowledge beyond nature, and that rational knowledge from sense experience is real knowledge. They did not believe in spiritual ideas or revealed knowledge.
Axiology: values in society keep changing. There are no spiritual values and no universal ultimate values. They accepted only natural morality and natural aesthetics; they did not accept traditional morality.
Naturalism: aims of education and curriculum
- Aims of education: free self-expression, development of the whole personality, adjustment to the surroundings, sublimation of instincts, development of the pupils' innate powers, development of individuality.
- Curriculum: education should help the pupil's self-preservation. The pupil should learn directly from nature itself through personal experiences. So nature is a big book for the pupil.
- Naturalists did not fix a set curriculum. Cultural subjects have no place in the curriculum.
- They gave importance to physics and chemistry, botany and zoology, and astronomy, which help the study of nature. A scientific outlook is given importance in establishing facts. Health, vocational life and family life are also part of the curriculum.
- Because they gave importance to reason, they gave no place to spiritualism, divine teaching or religious teaching.
- Moral values should not be taught directly; they should be built through personal experiences. They believed these depend on each person's own needs and natural qualities.
Naturalism: teaching methods, teacher and pupil
- Teaching methods: naturalism gives more importance to learning than to "teaching". Child-centred methods such as self-learning and direct experience. They suggested learning by doing, teaching through play (the play-way method), direct experience and self-directed educational inquiry.
- The roots of the Dalton method and the heuristic method lie in naturalist thought. In building scientific knowledge, the pupil was compared to a scientist, and the natural environment that helps learning to a laboratory.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
This is not a child centered method
- (1)Lecture method
- (2)Heuristic method
- (3)Assignment method
- (4)Project method
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (1) Lecture method
The question asks which of the given teaching methods is not child-centred.
Teaching methods can be teacher-centred or child-centred. In teacher-centred methods the teacher talks and the pupils listen. In child-centred methods the pupils learn by doing, finding out and thinking for themselves, while the teacher guides them.
In the lecture method the teacher explains and the pupils mostly listen; they play a passive role. So it is a teacher-centred method. The answer is option (1), Lecture method.
In the heuristic method (2) pupils find things out themselves through experiments. In the assignment method (3) pupils complete set tasks on their own. In the project method (4) pupils plan and solve a real-life problem. All three are child-centred.
Remember: Teacher talks, pupils listen (lecture) = teacher-centred.
- Teacher: in idealism the teacher runs everything from in front of the curtain; in naturalism he runs the story from behind the curtain. The teacher is neither a preacher nor an instructor; he is only a helper. Like a trellis (pandal), he supports the natural growth of children, who are like flowers. His work is only to create the right environment for the natural development of children. Naturalism says that how to learn and what to learn should be left to the pupils. The teacher should stay as an observer, a spectator, and come in only when a difficult situation arises.
- Pupil: the pupil is fully free in learning. Learning goes on according to the pupil's wishes, natural qualities and natural tendencies, without any fear or physical punishment.
Exam focus: Naturalism = the complete opposite of idealism; "Let us go back to nature"; "The senses are the gateways of knowledge"; no fixed curriculum; nature is the big book; root of the Dalton and heuristic methods; teacher = behind the curtain, helper, trellis; no physical punishment. Exponents: Rousseau, Pestalozzi, Herbert Spencer.
Memory code: "Idealist in front of the curtain, naturalist behind it" - the idealist teacher stands in front, the naturalist teacher stays behind. "RPS": Rousseau, Pestalozzi, Spencer = naturalists. "D-H = children of nature" - the Dalton and Heuristic methods have their root in naturalism.