Many educationists and scientists have given their views on disability. The way society looks at disability is called a model of disability. When the model changes, the approach to education also changes.
Models of disability
The two models most discussed in the field of international development are the medical model and the social model. Before them there was the charity view; after the UNCRPD, the rights view grew stronger.
| Model | How it sees disability | Result in education |
|---|---|---|
| Charity model | Persons with disabilities are people who should receive pity, kindness, service and alms | Special schools run by voluntary and charitable organisations |
| Medical model | Disability is a defect or weakness in the person; a fault that stays fixed. Theories focus on the person and his disability and try to "correct" it | Trying to "fix" the person and fit him into the school; segregation |
| Social model | The real cause of the problems of persons with disabilities is the environment around them, the services available and people's attitudes | Barriers in the environment, services and attitudes must be removed |
| Rights-based model | Persons with disabilities are citizens with equal rights with others | Education is a right; inclusive education |
- After the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948, the UNCRPD took the world's view of persons with disabilities away from kindness, service and charity and set it on the foundation of human rights (details of the Convention are in the "International Conventions" chapter).
Why is it hard to define?
- Defining disability is complex, because there are many kinds of disability groups and clear differences between them.
- Many people treat an impairment directly as a disability. Example: people with hearing impairment speak in sign language, so they are seen as persons with disabilities. But seen another way, sign language is like the difference between English, Telugu and Urdu - it is just a different language.
WHO classification: Impairment → Disability → Handicap
The World Health Organization (WHO) approved a classification showing the difference between these three terms at the World Health Assembly in 1976; it was published in 1980. Impairment leads to disability; disability leads to handicap.
| Term | Meaning | Level | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Impairment | Any loss or abnormality of psychological, physiological or anatomical structure or function | Body / organ level | Mental: reduced memory or recognition; internal physical: heart, kidneys; external: head, waist, legs, arms |
| Disability | A restriction or lack, resulting from an impairment, of the ability to do an activity in the manner or within the range considered normal for a human being | Person level | Being unable to walk because of a leg impairment |
| Handicap | A disadvantage for the person, resulting from an impairment or disability, that prevents or limits the fulfilment of a role that is normal for that person according to age, sex and social and cultural factors | Society level | Losing a chance in games or in a job because of being unable to walk |
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
"Disability" reflects the consequences of impairment in terms of functional performance and activity by the individual, is defined by
- (1)WHO, 1976
- (2)UNO, 1976
- (3)RCO, 1976
- (4)RTO, 1976
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (1) WHO, 1976
The question asks which body defined 'disability' as the result of an impairment on a person's functional performance and activity.
In 1976 the World Health Assembly of the World Health Organization (WHO) adopted a classification (ICIDH, published in 1980) that separated three terms. Impairment is a loss or defect in a body part or its structure. Disability is the resulting lack of ability to perform an activity in the normal way. Handicap is the disadvantage the person then faces in society.
So the answer is option (1), WHO, 1976.
The UNO (2) is the United Nations; health and disability definitions are the work of its specialised agency, WHO. RCO (3) and RTO (4) did not define disability; RTO is the road transport office.
Remember: Impairment → disability → handicap: the WHO model.
ICF: disability arises together with the environment
- Later, in 2001, WHO brought out the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF).
- According to the ICF, a condition should be recognised as a disability only when there are barriers between the person and the environment around him or people's attitudes.
- Example 1: A student with a physical impairment goes to school in a wheelchair. If the school has no ramp, he has trouble getting inside and using the toilet. His disability arises only because of environmental barriers.
- Example 2: A blind student studies with everyone in an inclusive school, with Braille books and the help of a special teacher. He faces neither environmental barriers nor attitudinal barriers, so he cannot be called a person with a disability.
Exam focus: Impairment → Disability → Handicap (WHO; approved 1976, published 1980). Impairment = loss in body structure / function; disability = restriction in the ability to do an activity (person level); handicap = disadvantage of being unable to fulfil a normal role (society level). ICF (2001) = disability is the result of barriers between the person + the environment. Medical model = the problem lies in the person; social model = the barrier lies in the environment.
Memory code: "IDH = BPS" - Impairment in the Body, Disability in the Person, Handicap in Society. Dates "76 - 80 - 2001": approved, published, ICF. Order of the models "CMSR": Charity → Medical → Social → Rights.