Change is unavoidable in life. But in an organised society with a large number of people, change is not easy. Change becomes necessary when new methods work better than the old services. Education is not just filling the brain with information; it is a process that builds a person's mental power and sharpens his personality. The difference between these four words - exclusion, segregation, integration and inclusion - must be clearly known.
Exclusion
- Keeping children away from school altogether; the education system does not admit them at all.
- Discrimination and exclusion are not limited to children with disabilities. Besides the children who never come to school, many of those who join cannot complete primary education.
- A UNESCO publication lists the groups of children who face exclusion: caste minorities, linguistic minorities, refugee or displaced children, child labourers, children of domestic workers, children with HIV / AIDS, children with disabilities, children of religious minorities, children in poverty, street children, children in conflict areas, child soldiers and nomadic children.
- Calling such children "backward" or "the lowest" hurts their personality and creates many problems in meeting their needs.
Segregation
- Segregated education is education in which children with special needs and children with disabilities study completely apart from children of their own age (their peer group).
- It usually takes the form of special schools set up only for learners with special needs, or of special classes run separately inside a regular school.
- Classes filled with learners who have one type or a few types of disability are called "special education classes".
- These learners have separate curricula and separate examination methods, not the regular curriculum.
- Teachers trained in special education are needed to teach learners with special needs; different training is needed for working with different disabilities.
- Segregation at school often leads to segregation in other areas of life as well.
Integration
- The word "integration" is basically a moral idea of keeping different cultures together. For cultures to come together, people must know, understand and respect one another. For this, no one needs to give up his own identity or focus only on differences.
- Integrated education is an educational approach that came with the aim of giving children with disabilities the chance to live and learn together with others in real life.
- Integrated education looks like inclusive education, but it has no ideological commitment to equity.
- In integration, learners are placed in the mainstream class with some adjustments and resources. But they are expected to adjust to the existing structures, attitudes and unchanged environment.
- Because the learners sit in the mainstream class, integration is often mistaken for inclusion. But unless there is a change in thinking in the school (a paradigm shift), these learners do not get an equal place.
- If teaching is done for only some, not for the understanding of everyone in the class, it is integration, not inclusion.
- The idea of mainstreaming first began in the United States of America. Its main aim is to bring persons with disabilities into the flow of life.
- Depending on how far the mixing has gone, it is described as partial integration (most of the time in a separate special class inside the regular school, with a special teacher and special resources) or full integration (the whole day in the regular class, with the support needed).
- Integrated classes are seen as a happy middle path between completely separate classes and classes where everyone is together.
- In India, the scheme that stands for this stage is IEDC: it had arrangements such as one special teacher for every 8 children with disabilities and one resource room for a cluster of 8-10 schools (details of the scheme are in the "Programmes and Schemes" chapter).
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
This is not related to Integrated Education
- (1)Partial Integration
- (2)Peripheral Integration
- (3)Total Integration
- (4)Gender Integration
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (4) Gender Integration
The question asks which term is not related to Integrated Education.
Integrated Education places children with special needs (CWSN) in regular schools. It is described by how much the child is integrated: partial integration (some periods in the regular class, the rest in a resource room), total integration (the whole day in the regular class); peripheral integration is likewise a term for the degree of integration. All of these are about including children with disabilities.
Gender integration (4) means boys and girls studying together (co-education). It has nothing to do with integrating children with disabilities, so the answer is option (4). Options (1), (2) and (3) are degrees of integration within Integrated Education, so they are related.
Remember: Integrated Education is about disability, not gender.
Choose the correct statement i. Partial integrated education means providing Special education in a special classroom with special resources by a special educator to CwSN in a general school ii. Inclusive education means providing education to CwSN in general school along with general students
- (1)i is correct
- (2)ii is correct
- (3)i & ii are correct
- (4)i & ii are not correct
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (3) i & ii are correct
The question gives two statements and asks which are correct.
Statement i: in partial integration, children with special needs (CWSN) attend a regular school but are taught in a separate special class, with special resources, by a special educator. They are in the school but spend much of their time outside the regular class, so the integration is only partial. This statement is correct.
Statement ii: in Inclusive Education, CWSN study in the regular school, in the regular class, along with their peers, and the school adapts to their needs. This is the approach of the RPwD Act 2016 and NEP 2020. This statement is also correct.
Both statements are correct, so the answer is option (3). Options (1) and (2) accept only one statement each, and option (4) rejects both, so they are wrong.
Remember: Partial integration = special class in a regular school; inclusion = same class for all.
For integrated education to succeed
Integrated education fails without the following:
- There must be special equipment.
- Everyone must support and cooperate with one another.
- There must be a special teacher.
- The curriculum must be adapted to suit the children.
- There must be a learning environment suited to them.
- There must be special teaching techniques that meet the educational needs of learners with special needs.
- There must be extra resources to meet the children's special needs.
- Children must be able to come to school and communicate properly.
Inclusion
- Inclusive education is educating children in the schools of their own neighbourhood, whatever their physical, mental, cognitive and social differences.
- Supporters of inclusive education believe that education must be universal, shared equally by all kinds of learners: no one should be left out; no one should get a separate, different education.
- Inclusion means giving the needed encouragement to groups kept away from school and society, so that they take part equally with everyone.
- Inclusive education is a process of strengthening the capacity of the school system to reach all learners. It involves restructuring the culture, policies and practices of schools.
- The words inclusion and mainstream are often used as synonyms. In general education, inclusion means 100% placement in the mainstream class. Even if a learner with special needs studies part of the time in a special programme, he should study in the regular education programme as far as possible.
- Inclusion does not only mean physically seating persons with disabilities in the same room. Learners who share the same space must also share the same state of mind (the feeling of being together).
- The benefit of inclusive classes: learners understand one another, learn from one another, and learn to respect differences and similarities.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
This education policy is being implemented in India for persons with disabilities
- (1)Special Education
- (2)Inclusive Education
- (3)Integrated Education
- (4)General Education
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (2) Inclusive Education
The question asks which approach India follows at present for the education of persons with disabilities.
Education of children with disabilities has passed through three stages: special education in separate schools, then integrated education where the child joins a regular school with extra help (IEDC, 1974), and now inclusive education, where the school itself adapts to every child. The RPwD Act 2016, NEP 2020 and Samagra Shiksha all call for inclusive education.
So the answer is option (2), inclusive education.
Special education (1) still exists for severe disabilities but is not the main policy. Integrated education (3) is the earlier stage, where the child had to adjust to the school. General education (4) gives no special support.
Remember: Special → Integrated → Inclusive (now).
Children With Special Needs are not to be enrolled in
- (1)Regular schools
- (2)Adult education centers
- (3)Schools attached with Hostels
- (4)Gurukulams
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (2) Adult education centers
The question asks where children with special needs (CWSN) should not be enrolled.
Under inclusive education, children with disabilities study in any school along with children of their own age. The RTE and RPwD Acts say no school may turn them away. Adult education centres, however, are meant for adults who missed schooling; they are not schools for children.
So the answer is option (2), Adult education centers.
Regular schools (1), schools with hostels (3) and Gurukulams (4) are all schools for children. Enrolling CWSN in them is exactly what inclusive education wants.
Remember: Adult education is for adults, not for children.
Inclusive education as UNESCO sees it
| Point | Meaning |
|---|---|
| One ministry | One ministry is responsible for the education of all children |
| One school system | One school system is responsible for the education of all children in its area |
| Mixed classes | Classes hold all kinds of learners together |
| Strategies for diversity | Teachers use strategies such as multi-level teaching, cooperative learning, individualised learning methods, guided learning and peer tutoring |
| Collaboration | Teachers, administrators and others work together to respond to each learner's needs |
- The key point of the UNESCO (2005) definition: inclusion is a process - a never-ending search for better ways of responding to diversity. It teaches how to live with diversity and how to learn from differences. It sees differences as a positive stimulus for promoting learning among children and adults.
The three approaches compared
| Point | Segregation | Integration | Inclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where the child studies | Special school / a completely separate class | Regular school, with some adjustments | Regular school near home, regular class |
| Who must change | No one; the child is separated | The child must adjust to the school | The school must change to suit the child |
| Curriculum and examinations | Separate | Regular ones, with some adaptations | A flexible curriculum for all that responds to diversity |
| Commitment to equity | None | No ideological commitment | Yes; restructuring of school culture, policies and practices |
| Underlying idea | "They cannot be taught together" | "They can be brought in with support" | "All must learn together" - a right |
- Given the resources in our country and the number of learners with special needs, reaching everyone is hard. Even so, India has moved from special education to integrated education and from there towards inclusive education, with some success.
- Inclusive education is a new approach that teaches children with disabilities and regular children who have learning problems together, under one roof. Special education separates them from others, but in real life they must live together with others. Even children with severe disabilities should learn within the community.
Exam focus: Segregation = completely apart from peers, separate curriculum and examinations. Integration = in the mainstream class, with adjustments + resources, but no commitment to equity; the child must adjust. Inclusion = a process that strengthens the capacity of the school; restructuring of culture, policies and practices; the school must change. The idea of mainstreaming began first in the USA. What India is implementing now is inclusive education.
Memory code: "ESII" - Exclusion (outside) → Segregation (beside) → Integration (inside, but separate) → Inclusion (all together). In integration "the child changes", in inclusion "the school changes". What inclusion restructures: "CPP" - Culture, Policies, Practices.