What is autonomy?
- Psychological autonomy is an old idea describing a way of living and behaving that is unique to human beings. Philosophers and researchers have debated it for centuries.
- The debate has recently started again because of the rise of positive psychology and the economics of happiness, and because of dissatisfaction with the behaviourist and cognitivist approaches.
- People fight for freedom not only because oppression hurts; research suggests that we are naturally made to desire autonomy.
- Definition: the ability to make choices according to one's own free will. What matters is not whether that will is truly free but whether it feels free.
- If one feels forced, by internal pressure such as guilt or shame or by external pressure from others, the sense of autonomy disappears.
Autonomy and psychological development
| Thinker | On autonomy |
|---|---|
| Abraham Maslow | The goal of human development is "self-actualisation"; the most developed person is the most autonomous |
| Carl Rogers | The goal of human development is "becoming a person"; autonomy means not depending on others |
| Lawrence Kohlberg | Moral development: more developed people show more moral autonomy and independence in their judgements. The highest stage resembles Kant's moral ideal of adopting universal values as one's own |
| Carol Gilligan | Criticised Kohlberg: his model describes men's development, not women's. For women, identity means not only separation but also closeness (connection). Growth means balancing one's own interests with those of others |
- Gilligan did not reject autonomy completely. Her criticism led to feminist ethics and to the idea of "relational autonomy".
Personal autonomy
- When modern philosophy discusses personal autonomy, it sets aside psychological development ideas such as self-actualisation. It focuses on the structure that decides whether an action is autonomous.
- This differs from Kant's moral autonomy: an action is judged not by universal principles but by the internal features of the person's own decision-making process.
| Type | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Content-neutral view | Does not lay down any values that an autonomous person must accept |
| Substantive view | Lays down certain values that must be present in an autonomous decision |
Exam focus: Autonomy = the ability to make choices by one's own free will (feeling free is what matters). Maslow = self-actualisation; Rogers = becoming a person. Kohlberg = moral development, moral autonomy. Gilligan = criticism of Kohlberg, closeness in women's development, relational autonomy. Two views of personal autonomy: content-neutral and substantive.
Memory code: "Maslow Actualises, Rogers Becomes, Kohlberg Moralises, Gilligan Relates": Maslow = self-actualisation; Rogers = becoming a person; Kohlberg = moral development; Gilligan = relational autonomy (closeness).