Why do emotions matter?
- Emotions are key in adjusting to everyday challenges. When the mood is good, even hard work feels easy; when one is sad, even an entertainment programme feels heavy.
- Emotions also affect relationships with others. If we laugh when a friend tells us something painful, we look rude; if we flare up at a small annoyance, we look aggressive and unstable.
- Infants scream with joy and cry with anger. But society expects adults to keep the display of their feelings under control.
- Emotions are not completely controlled by the body's make-up, as reflexes are. One need not be a lifelong prisoner of the emotional pattern in one's DNA; feelings can be managed.
Theories of emotion
| Theory | Proposed by | Key idea |
|---|
| James-Lange theory | William James (father of American psychology) and physiologist Carl Lange | The bodily responses (heartbeat, sweating) are the emotion. The bodily reaction does not come after the emotion; it is the emotion. "We are afraid because we tremble; we are sad because we cry" |
| Cannon-Bard theory | Physiologist Walter Cannon and his doctoral student Philip Bard | The thalamus in the brain manages emotions. The stimulus causes the bodily reaction and the felt emotion in the brain at the same time |
| ABC model (rational emotive approach) | Albert Ellis | Our thoughts create our distress. "Must" thoughts such as "I must win" and "Everyone must love me" rule our feelings |
- The James-Lange theory was criticised (by Cannon and Bard) because it did not stand up to scientific tests. The Cannon-Bard theory also did not hold up under experimental study. Although the thalamus takes part in some emotional control, the amygdala is the important part for feelings such as fear and anger.
Ellis' ABC model
| Letter | Meaning | Example |
|---|
| A | Activating event | A friend turned down an invitation |
| B | Belief about the event | "Nobody likes me" |
| C | Consequence - the emotion | Sadness, despair |
- For the resulting emotion (C) to change, the belief (B) must change. To change the belief, it must be examined: "If one person says no, does it mean nobody likes me? Will nobody ever like me? Must everyone like me?"
- By recognising and challenging the irrational basis, one can be freed from unhelpful feelings such as anger, jealousy, a sense of rejection and sorrow, and can build helpful feelings such as happiness, contentment and joy. Focusing on the thought that comes before the feeling helps control the mood.
Are feelings good or bad?
- All feelings are natural; they are neither good nor bad. Thoughts and feelings hurt nobody; only actions can hurt, so actions can be bad.
- From this view, feelings need not be hidden (unless expressing them would hurt someone), and there is no need to feel guilty about thoughts.
- Yet how do we come to believe that feelings are bad? If a 5-year-old who hit his younger brother is slapped and told "Don't do that", he cannot grasp that "hitting is wrong, feeling angry is not wrong"; he grows up thinking "feeling angry itself is wrong".
9 ways in which feelings come out
| No. | Way | Example |
|---|
| 1 | Acting on the feeling | Shouting in anger, crying in sorrow |
| 2 | Bodily reactions | Face turning red with shyness, blood pressure rising with anxiety |
| 3 | Suppressing and denying | Those who suppress feelings have higher blood pressure and heart rate, weaker immunity, sleep problems and aches |
| 4 | Trying to change the situation | Shouting orders when something goes wrong; saying "Shut up" signals anger but does not state it directly |
| 5 | Hiding one feeling behind another | Crying when angry; fearful dependence behind love |
| 6 | Blaming others instead of taking responsibility | Saying "You are selfish" instead of "I was hurt" |
| 7 | The feeling has an effect even when its nature is not known | Feelings of an unconscious personality in people with multiple personalities |
| 8 | Sharing honestly | Needs "I" statements, social skills, assertiveness skills and self-confidence |
| 9 | Using feelings as a measure | Negative feelings are a signal that something must change and that self-help is needed |
Ways of changing feelings
- An emotion has four parts: behaviour, feeling, bodily reaction and thought. Understanding these shows ways of changing them.
- Changing the surroundings / behaviour: putting strong locks on doors to reduce fear; staying away from people who make one angry; watching less fearful people to reduce one's own fear.
- Opposite behaviours: activity reduces depression, assertiveness reduces anger, facing the situation reduces fear, and relaxation reduces the rush of those who overwork.
- Repeated exposure: facing the situation or memory again and again while relaxed reduces the feeling. But talking with friends about a "terrible" event and getting very upset again usually does not help.
- Changing the consequences: asking friends to praise a healthy decision.
- Changing thoughts (cognitive methods): thoughts strongly affect feelings. These methods are used for basic feelings such as anxiety/fear, anger and sadness. For dependency problems, cognitive-behavioural methods and new skills are used.
Exam focus: James-Lange = the bodily reaction is the emotion ("afraid because we tremble"). Cannon-Bard = thalamus; bodily reaction and felt emotion at the same time. The amygdala is key for fear and anger. Ellis = ABC model, "must" thoughts; to change C, change B. Feelings are neither good nor bad; only actions can hurt. Feelings come out in 9 ways.
Memory code: "James-Lange = Body, Cannon-Bard = Brain (thalamus), Ellis = Belief" (three Bs). ABC = Activating event, Belief, Consequence.