A leadership style is the characteristic behaviour a leader shows while directing, motivating, guiding and managing a group of people. Great leaders inspire political movements and social change; they encourage others to perform well, to create and to innovate. Leaders differ greatly in the way they lead; researchers have developed theories and frameworks to understand these differences. The teacher / guide who runs group guidance is also a group leader.
Lewin's leadership styles (1939)
Kurt Lewin recognised that the need to take decisions is one factor that determines a leader's style. In 1939 he and his colleagues (Lippitt and White) identified three leadership styles in decision-making:
| Style | Whose decision | Feature |
|---|---|---|
| Autocratic | The leader's alone | Does not consult or involve followers; imposes the decision and expects obedience |
| Democratic | The leader + others | Takes an active part in decision-making and involves others too; not everything has to be put to a vote; the leader is responsible for the results |
| Laissez-faire | Mostly the followers' | The leader's role is very small; works if followers are capable and motivated, otherwise problems arise |
Other leadership styles
Besides Lewin's three styles, researchers have described many more. The best known are:
Transformational leadership:
- The leader works with subordinates to identify the needed change, creates a vision that guides the change through inspiration, and carries out the change together with committed members.
- It raises followers' motivation, morale and job performance by:
- linking the followers' identity and self-concept to the project and to the collective identity of the organisation
- inspiring them and raising their interest by being a role model
- challenging them to take more responsibility for their work
- understanding followers' strengths and weaknesses and giving them tasks that improve their performance
Transactional leadership:
- It is also called managerial leadership. The focus is on supervision, organisation and performance.
- The leader makes followers obey the rules through both rewards and punishments.
- Unlike transformational leaders, the leader does not try to change the future; he tries to keep things as they are. He watches followers' work to spot errors and deviations from the rules.
- It works effectively in crisis and emergency situations and in tasks that must be done in one specific way.
| Point | Transformational | Transactional |
|---|---|---|
| Goal | Change, vision | Keeping the existing state |
| Means | Inspiration, role model | Rewards and punishments |
| Focus | Followers' motivation and responsibility | Supervision, finding errors |
| Works best | In organisations that need change | In crisis and emergency situations |
Situational leadership: Hersey and Blanchard
- Situational leadership was developed and studied by Kenneth Blanchard and Paul Hersey.
- The leader must adjust his style to the readiness (maturity) of the followers he wants to influence. It is the leader who must change, not the follower. The style can keep changing with the situation.
- The Hersey-Blanchard model is one of the best-known situational theories. It was first published in 1969. In this original model the leader matches his style to the followers' maturity / readiness. It has four main styles:
| No. | Style | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Telling | Telling people what to do |
| 2 | Selling | Persuading followers to accept the leader's ideas |
| 3 | Participating | Giving members a more active role in decision-making |
| 4 | Delegating | Leaving most decisions to the members, without the leader stepping in |
Blanchard's SLII styles
Blanchard later expanded the original model into SLII (1985, with Patricia and Drea Zigarmi). In SLII the development level of the learners (followers) - their skill and commitment - decides the style the leader should use. This too has four styles:
| No. | Style | Direction | Support |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Directing | High (gives clear instructions and supervises closely) | Low |
| 2 | Coaching | High | High |
| 3 | Supporting | Low | High |
| 4 | Delegating | Low | Low |
- Some of these styles look only roughly like Lewin's three basic styles: directing is a little like the autocratic style, and delegating a little like the laissez-faire style. The difference: a directing leader still explains the task and supervises closely, and delegating is a deliberate handover to capable followers, not simply leaving them alone.
Exam focus: Lewin 1939 = autocratic, democratic, laissez-faire. Autocratic = the leader alone decides; laissez-faire = left to the followers. Transformational = change, vision, role model; transactional (managerial) = rewards and punishments, keeping what exists, effective in crises. Situational = Hersey and Blanchard; it is the leader who must change. Hersey-Blanchard 1969 (followers' maturity / readiness): telling, selling, participating, delegating. SLII (1985, development level): directing, coaching, supporting, delegating.
Memory code: Lewin "A-D-L 39" = Autocratic, Democratic, Laissez-faire - 1939. Hersey-Blanchard "Tell, Sell, Participate, Delegate - 69" = Telling, Selling, Participating, Delegating - 1969. Transactional = "a reward-punishment bargain", transformational = "a dream of change".