Group guidance has an important place in school guidance programmes. It helps each student and his problems in ten ways.
Ten benefits of group guidance
- More chances of contact: students get to know more friends with similar problems, and good rapport develops. In a friendly, cooperative atmosphere everyone comes forward and shares problems; one problem gets many solutions from many minds. "We sink together, we swim together" becomes everyone's motto; students grow close like brothers and sisters of one family.
- Encouragement for the average (ordinary) student: the main purpose is to help each student in the group. Groups are usually formed of average students. They get useful information and ways of solving problems; then the student tries to manage his own life situation himself.
- A favourable setting for discussing common problems: united effort is the key element of group guidance. Common problems faced by many or all are discussed directly under the expert leadership of teachers / guidance workers; working together, everyone solves the problems correctly and easily.
- Better attitudes and behaviour of students: discussing common and personal problems leads to a free exchange of opinions and a realistic analysis of attitudes. A way to the solution is found with balanced judgement and desirable behaviour.
- Importance to group judgement: out of shyness, some students do not tell their important personal problems to an interviewer; they do not want their weaknesses exposed. But in a group everyone is "birds of a feather", so they are willing to share hidden problems. Then a group judgement on the individual's problems emerges; group judgement does not leave out the problems common to the whole group either.
- Chance for observation: the guidance worker can observe a student's response, behaviour and feelings towards a problem or towards group living. This reveals the students' personality traits and mental state; that information is useful for later guidance services.
- All-round personality development: students of different family backgrounds, educational levels and socio-economic levels take part; this leads to better adjustment. In a friendly atmosphere everyone gets a chance to express himself; this cooperative atmosphere develops the personality as a whole.
- Awareness of unrecognised needs and problems: students' hidden and unrecognised needs and problems come out through group interaction, group closeness and group freedom. The guidance worker keeps them in mind and gives suitable guidance.
- Saves time: it works with many students at once, so time is saved. Individual guidance needs a lot of time and attention; in group guidance everyone is served in a limited time.
- Saves money: individual guidance is a costly process: it needs a special guidance worker, special methods of collecting information and extra human resources. In group guidance many people get the same kind of service, so the cost is low.
Individual and group guidance: a comparison
| Point | Individual guidance | Group guidance |
|---|---|---|
| For whom | One student, one at a time | Many students at once |
| Time | Needs much time and attention | Saves time |
| Cost | Costly: a special worker, special methods, extra human resources | Low cost |
| Shy student | May not tell the problem to an interviewer | Shares hidden problems among "birds of a feather" |
| Judgement | The guide's advice | Group judgement |
| Ways | Individual counselling, interview | Group techniques such as career talk, case conference, question box |
- The two do not compete with each other; individual counselling is used when a problem is deep, and group guidance for common problems.
Exam focus: Ten benefits of group guidance: more contacts ("we sink together, we swim together"), encouragement for the average student, discussion of common problems, better attitudes and behaviour, group judgement ("birds of a feather"), chance for observation, all-round personality development, awareness of unrecognised needs, saves time, saves money. Individual guidance is costly and takes more time.
Memory code: The ten benefits "C-A-C-A-J / O-W-U-T-M" = Contacts, Average student, Common problems, Attitudes, Judgement (group) / Observation, Whole personality, Unrecognised needs, Time, Money. The last two: "Time and Money - both saved = group".