All democratic countries are working for equal opportunities. According to Dr. S. Radhakrishnan, in a democracy everyone must have equal opportunities for development without inequality.
What equality is and what it is not
- Equality does not mean uniformity; nor does it mean the absence of differences. No two people in society are alike.
- Equal opportunity does not mean the same kind of education for everyone. People's opinions, attitudes and beliefs differ.
- Equality of educational opportunity means giving everyone an equal chance in educational institutions, without any rich-poor difference; removing the barriers of caste, religion and class, and giving education that suits each person's abilities and interests.
- An equal chance for every person on the basis of his abilities; equal educational opportunities for everyone regardless of race, caste, religion or birth.
- Providing equal opportunities means removing the barriers between individuals so that they can reach their goals.
Importance of equality of educational opportunity
- A democratic system progresses only when education is given to everyone. Equal opportunities in education decide the modernisation of a country.
- Equal opportunities bring out the talent in individuals; relations between individuals improve, and human resources develop.
- Indian Education Commission (1964-66): education is a social goal; education helps to improve the condition of the poor and the weaker sections. Equity, values and equal progress must be ensured for all sections of society.
- Under Article 45, equal educational opportunities must be given to everyone below 14 years; that is why elementary education was made free, compulsory and universal. It was decided that education must be given to everyone at the elementary stage without any discrimination.
Problems of inequality: differences in socio-economic conditions, gender inequalities, regional inequalities, lack of chances to rise in society (social mobility), and differences in physical and mental abilities.
Equality and equity (fairness)
- Those with equal ability and merit must be given an equal chance.
- Causes of inequality: gaps between social classes; losing a chance because of inequality in one matter leads to more inequalities. Research shows how people's life chances are affected.
- Equity means acting with fairness (impartially). Equality is not possible without fairness; fairness supports equality.
- "Equity" has two meanings: equality and fairness.
- According to Bronfenbrenner (1973), equality means social justice; it is related to moral judgement.
- To achieve fairness in education, the law must make sure there is no discrimination against the backward / weaker sections of society. Developing countries too must choose equality and fairness as goals of education policy.
Social equality and equality of educational opportunity
- The idea of equality of educational opportunity has changed over different stages of history. Its meaning now: everyone starts together, everyone benefits, and everyone moves forward together.
- According to the National Policy on Education 1986, equality in education means providing equal opportunities to all, and also making sure the conditions (facilities) needed to succeed with those opportunities are there.
- Ways to achieve it: physical facilities, materials in schools, teachers, curriculum, financial help to poor children. In another view, equality in education means a common curriculum.
Importance of social equality in education
- In a democracy the people elect the government; electing a good government is our duty. The awareness to recognise rights and duties comes only through education.
- Education is needed to build brotherhood in a democratic country; through education, moral qualities, social abilities, patience and helpfulness develop.
- For a good democracy every citizen must know his rights and duties and must be a partner in the development of the country and society.
- For democracy to progress, all citizens must believe in democratic principles. Only educated people can build human values by recognising equality.
- Universal education for all is needed for social, economic and political equality. Educated people know their rights and fight against economic, political and social exploitation.
- Education helps to pass on culture and traditions from one generation to the next.
- Learning has become a burden and a stress for children and parents; this is lowering the quality of education. To correct this, the National Curriculum Framework (NCF) gave 5 guiding principles for curriculum development - connecting knowledge to life outside school, moving away from rote methods and so on (details in the chapter "National education commissions and policies").
Constitutional and policy provisions for equal opportunity (at a glance)
The Preamble of the Constitution guarantees equality to all citizens. Democracy, socialism, secularism and equality make it possible to build an equal society through equal opportunities in education. The full details of the Articles are in the chapter "Constitutional provisions on education".
| Provision | Guarantee of equal opportunity |
|---|---|
| Articles 15, 17, 46 | Educational protection for weaker sections; 15(1) - no discrimination against any citizen; 15(3) - special provisions may be made for women and children |
| Article 46 | Promoting the educational and economic interests of Dalits, tribal people and weaker sections; protection from social injustice and exploitation |
| Articles 25(1), 28 | Freedom of religion; no religious instruction in schools run wholly with government funds; in schools run with government aid, no one is forced into religious prayers without the guardian's consent |
| Articles 29(1), 30 | The right to preserve a distinct language, script and culture; the right of religious and linguistic minorities to set up and run educational institutions of their choice; no discrimination in giving grants |
| Article 350B | A special officer to protect the rights of linguistic minorities |
| Article 351 | Spread of the Hindi language |
| Union List entries 63, 66 | Banaras Hindu, Aligarh Muslim and Delhi universities and institutions of national importance; coordination and standards in higher education and scientific and technical institutions |
- Since our country has many languages, special priority was given after Independence to teaching in the mother tongue; facilities must be provided for linguistic minorities to be taught in their mother tongue at the primary level.
- Treating everyone equally without differences of caste, religion, region or race is a fundamental right. Equal opportunities are not meaningful unless they help education.
Equality measures suggested by various commissions: (1) abolishing tuition fees; (2) reducing private fees; (3) scholarships; (4) equipment for students; (5) reducing regional inequalities; (6) education of women; (7) education of backward sections - including the education of tribal people.
Areas the National Policy on Education 1986 focused on for equality: education of women; educational opportunities for backward sections; education of minorities; education of persons with disabilities; continuing and adult education.
Tools: free compulsory education, universal education, Operation Blackboard, a curriculum with diversity, Navodaya schools, distance education.
Exam focus: Equality ≠ uniformity; equal opportunity ≠ the same kind of education. Equal opportunity = removing barriers and giving education that suits ability and interest. Equity = fairness; two meanings (equality, fairness). Bronfenbrenner (1973): equality = social justice. NPE 1986: equal opportunity + conditions for success. Kothari Commission 1964-66: education to improve the condition of the poor and weaker sections. The present idea: everyone starts together, benefits together and moves forward together.
Memory code: "Equality = one box each, Equity = as many boxes as needed". The two meanings of equity "E-F": Equality, Fairness. The present idea "Together - 3": start together, benefit together, progress together. Bronfenbrenner "73 = social justice".