Literacy and education: why a right?
- According to Paulo Freire (1973), literacy does not mean only reading and writing; it means having the ability to understand and being able to communicate in writing.
- Literacy can also be described as an attitude that builds creativity, an attitude of re-creating, and a change in self-transformation.
- Education is essential for people to enjoy all human rights. Education supports social identity and personal identity; it is a key tool for national development and economic progress. It gives awareness of rights and removes injustice and discrimination in society. Education is also part of the right to life. There is no dignity without education; education carries the main responsibility for fully achieving the idea of a welfare state.
The right to education internationally
- Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948, and its Article 26: everyone has the right to education. Education must be free and compulsory at the elementary stage. Education must support the full development of personality, respect for basic freedoms, and tolerance and friendship between races and religions. Access to education is needed for children's development and self-confidence.
- The basic foundation of the right to education is Articles 13 and 14 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR, 1966).
- Other agreements that brought the right to education to light: the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW, 1979), the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC, 1989), the African Charter on Human Rights (1981), and the declarations of the Council of Europe on human rights education.
- An Additional Protocol of 1988 came into force on 16 November 1999. It said that the duty of promoting social, economic and cultural rights along with the right to education lies with the states, and that they must take protective measures without discrimination.
- The full details of these conventions are in the chapter "International conventions and policies".
What Article 13 (ICESCR) says
- Priority to free and compulsory primary education.
- Secondary education must be free, available and accessible.
- Higher education must be available and accessible to all.
- Basic education for those who could not complete primary education.
- Article 13 speaks of rights but explains them only briefly. So the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, explaining Article 13, gave the "4A" framework.
4A framework: the three elements described here
| Element | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Availability | The government provides proper buildings, facilities and trained teachers for free education |
| Accessibility | Bringing favourable policies and facilities to the most marginalised sections, without discrimination in the education system |
| Acceptability | Education that is free of discrimination, culturally suitable, of good quality and safe; content that suits the needs of society and is accepted by society |
The three duties of states
When a country ratifies an education agreement, the duty to respect and protect the right to education is its own:
- Respect: giving enough freedom without interfering in the right to education.
- Protect: making sure that parents or others do not stop girls from going to school; lawful measures to prevent it.
- Fulfil: suitable measures to implement the right to education completely; special measures for minorities and people of different cultures. Economic, social and cultural rights also help in achieving the right to education.
Core obligation and proper measures
- Core obligation: free and compulsory primary education for all boys and girls without discrimination. Freedom for parents to choose a suitable school, and arrangements that protect the freedom of individuals in educational institutions.
- The right must be fulfilled using the available resources to the maximum. Lack of resources must not be taken as an excuse for not implementing the right. Backward (retrogressive) steps must not be taken; what is already in force must not be withdrawn.
- If states violate the right, legal action must be taken. Violations must be reported from time to time.
- In some countries it is not implemented because of lack of resources and political forces; the constitutions of some countries do not even mention the right to education. Education is out of reach for backward groups and groups that face discrimination. So awareness of the right to education must be raised, and people must be taught how to use it.
The right to education in India
- Education is a fundamental right of everyone; education is essential for democracy to succeed. Education supports personal development and national development.
- The Constitution first placed education not in Part III (Fundamental Rights) but in Part IV (Directive Principles). Even after 60 years, the directives were not acted on properly; at that stage 40% of the country was illiterate.
- The Unnikrishnan case judgement: education is a fundamental right of children aged 6-14.
- As demand grew from all sides, the 86th Constitutional Amendment (2002) added Article 21A and made free and compulsory education for children aged 6-14 a fundamental right.
- The bill for the Right to Education Act 2009 was introduced in the Rajya Sabha in December; the President gave assent on 26 August 2009; it came into force from 1 April 2010.
RTE Act 2009: key features related to universalisation
The full details of the Act are in the chapter "National acts: RCI, PWD, National Trust, RTE, RPwD". Only the main points are given here:
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| For whom? | Free and compulsory elementary education for boys and girls aged 6-14 |
| Board examination | No board examination until elementary education is completed |
| Certificate | After studying up to Class 8 |
| Teachers' qualification | Must get the professional qualification within 5 years of joining the job; otherwise they lose the job |
| Infrastructure | Must be provided within 3 years; otherwise recognition is cancelled |
| Reservation | 25% for the economically weaker sections in private and other schools |
| Management committee | 75% of the members are parents / guardians |
| Funds | The central and state governments share the financial burden |
| Weaker sections | Children of families whose income is below the minimum annual income limit fixed by the government |
| Recognition | Government recognition is compulsory for every school; minimum facilities, a proper teacher-pupil ratio and qualified teachers |
| Special category schools | Such as Kendriya Vidyalayas, Sainik Schools and Navodaya schools |
- The Act rests on the principle of raising standards and promoting equality by removing discrimination. It protects the right of students to learn in an environment free of fear and anxiety.
Benefits of the right to education
- It is a formal right; a support for backward sections and the poor.
- Through the right to education, one can learn about other rights.
- It helps the full development of personality.
- For those who could not get elementary education, the right to education stands as a fundamental right.
- Access to higher education on the basis of ability.
- Parents can enrol their children in any school, regardless of religion or caste.
- Individuals can freely set up educational institutions and run schools while following minimum standards.
Equality and social justice: six dimensions
Education is a powerful tool for social change. Equality and social justice in school must grow through the curriculum and through educational institutions, in the direction shown by the Constitution; even after school ends, the student must be in a position to understand them. For this, attention must be paid to six dimensions:
- Gender
- Economic differences
- Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
- Cultural factors
- Disability
- Rural and urban areas
When all these matters are included in the curriculum, children's self-confidence grows. Sustainable development means human, social and economic development.
Exam focus: Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948, Article 26 = right to education. ICESCR 1966, Articles 13 and 14 = the basic foundation of the right to education. CEDAW 1979, CRC 1989. 4A framework: Availability, Accessibility, Acceptability. Duties of states: respect, protect, fulfil. Unnikrishnan case → 86th Amendment 2002 → Article 21A → RTE 2009 (assent 26 August 2009, in force 1 April 2010). "Lack of resources" is no excuse.
Memory code: International sequence "48 - 66 - 79 - 89" = Human rights declaration (Article 26) → Economic-social rights covenant (13, 14) → Women (CEDAW) → Children (CRC): "H-E-W-C". Duties "RPF": Respect, Protect, Fulfil. India's sequence "U-86-21A-RTE" (Unnikrishnan → 86th Amendment → Article 21A → RTE Act).