It has been agreed internationally that reports and policies should be prepared after researching the progress and specific problems of different countries. Rights-based inclusive education at the school level needs facilities in all schools, a quality environment for students and teachers, and development at the system level. That is why a systematic approach must be followed across the whole education sector.
What is the rights-based model?
- The rights-based model is a framework, built on international human rights standards, used to plan programmes in a systematic way.
- It is a sharp tool for inclusive education: gender issues, non-discrimination in the curriculum, learner-centred teaching-learning methods in a suitable environment, the participation of all stakeholders and a holistic approach are all possible with it.
- Standards should be developed from a human rights point of view, not from a service-delivery point of view.
- According to UNICEF, if education is given to all children with the rights-based model, the problem of gender discrimination is also solved.
- This approach is holistic; it considers all civil, cultural, economic, political and social rights.
The PANEL principles
The main principles of the rights-based approach are given in the short form PANEL:
| Letter | Principle | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| P | Participation | Active, free and meaningful participation for everyone - beneficiaries, local communities, civil society, minorities and women |
| A | Accountability | Accountability and transparency at all levels; remedies when rights are violated |
| N | Non-discrimination and equality | Treating everyone equally without bias |
| E | Empowerment | The power and ability of people to know their rights and claim them |
| L | Legality / linkage to human rights standards | Recognising rights as legally enforceable rights |
- Rights-holders and duty-bearers: this approach identifies rights-holders and duty-bearers. Duty-bearers have two kinds of duties:
- Positive duty - taking steps so that rights are realised.
- Negative duty - keeping away from violating rights.
- Duty-bearers include individuals, governments, local bodies, lenders and private organisations. The primary responsibility lies with states and governments. International cooperation is also needed to increase resources and capacity in developing countries.
- Rights-based education means: (1) spreading knowledge of international human rights standards through educational programmes; (2) developing actions, skills and capacities at the national level for putting these standards into practice.
Human rights principles that strengthen the rights-based approach
The UN Common Understanding on the rights-based approach (2003) lists six principles of human rights; some sources add empowerment as a seventh. They support the development of laws and the practice of inclusive education:
- Universality and inalienability - human rights belong to every person everywhere in the world; no one can give them up voluntarily, and others cannot take them away.
- Indivisibility - cultural, civil, economic, political and social rights are all inherently needed for the dignity of every person.
- Interdependence and interrelatedness - the realisation of one right often depends, partly or fully, on other rights.
- Equality and non-discrimination - everyone is entitled to rights without any kind of discrimination.
- Participation and inclusion - free, active and meaningful participation for everyone in civil, social, political and cultural development.
- Accountability and rule of law - increasing accountability at all levels and respecting the rule of law.
The seventh principle some sources add: empowerment - the process by which people use their rights and increase their capacities; through it, a better life and community development.
All these principles are needed to promote the education of children with disabilities; through them they also gain other rights.
Child rights and disability: duties on the right to education
- According to the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) and the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD), every right that ordinary persons have also applies to persons with disabilities. In the CRC, Article 28 (education for all, free and compulsory primary education, reducing dropout) and Article 29 (the aims of education) relate to education; CRPD Article 24 speaks about inclusive education at all levels (other Articles are in the international conventions chapter).
- The Committee on the Rights of the Child identified four general principles: non-discrimination, the best interests of the child, the right to life and development, and respect for the child's views.
- Governments have three duties regarding the right to education:
| Duty | What must be done? |
|---|---|
| Fulfil | Providing physical changes, transport, the necessary changes in the curriculum, equipment and resources for quality inclusive education |
| Respect | Equal opportunity for children of different groups; preventing policies that stop children with disabilities from coming to school |
| Protect | Creating an environment in school that protects children with disabilities from violence and from harassment by teachers |
- What governments and representatives must do for the goals of inclusive education: improve existing policies; funds for every school; changes in buildings; setting up resource centres; an inclusive school culture in which everyone takes part; support so that parents send their children to school; a spirit of cooperation and values through opportunities to learn together; increasing respect and acceptance through community-based inclusive education.
Uses of the rights-based approach
- It clearly identifies people's rights and the duties to be carried out.
- It increases accountability and transparency; it removes inequalities.
- It increases equal opportunities and justice; it leads to institutional changes in national policy.
- It leads to meaningful, non-discriminatory teaching-learning and a good learning environment.
- It increases empowerment through community participation, using local resources.
Exam focus: PANEL = participation, accountability, non-discrimination-equality, empowerment, legality. Primary responsibility = governments. 3 duties on the right to education: fulfil, respect, protect. CRC education = Articles 28, 29; CRPD inclusive education = Article 24. Standards from a human rights point of view, not a service point of view.
Memory code: Duties on the right to education "F-R-P" ("Fully Respect and Protect") = Fulfil, Respect, Protect. CRC education "28 - 29" (right, aims) - CRPD 24: "28 gives the right, 29 gives the aims, 24 brings us all together".