Counselling is described in three approaches, depending on who leads the counselling process.
Directive counselling
- This is called counsellor-centred counselling. The person who made this approach well known is E.G. Williamson.
- The counsellor plays an active role: he gives information, explains, interprets and gives advice.
- Intellectual aspects get more importance than emotional aspects. It takes less time.
Non-directive counselling
- This is called client-centred counselling. Its originator is Carl Rogers. In Rogers' view, the therapeutic process should be non-directive.
- The client is the centre of the process. The counsellor gives no orders; he creates an atmosphere in which the client can express his feelings freely.
- The aim is not to give a solution to one problem; it is to help the client grow independent and solve his problems himself. It takes more time.
Eclectic counselling
- This is the middle path between the directive and non-directive approaches. It was put forward by F.C. Thorne.
- The counsellor is neither over-active as in the directive approach nor fully passive as in the non-directive approach. He uses tools from both approaches according to the client's need.
| Point | Directive | Non-directive | Eclectic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Centre | Counsellor | Client | Both, according to need |
| Originator | E.G. Williamson | Carl Rogers | F.C. Thorne |
| Counsellor's role | Active, gives advice | Listens, accepts | Changes with the situation |
| Emphasis | Intellectual aspects | Feelings, independence | Both |
| Time | Less | More | According to need |
Exam focus: Directive = counsellor-centred = Williamson. Non-directive = client-centred = Carl Rogers. Eclectic = middle path = Thorne. The directive approach stresses intellectual aspects; the non-directive approach stresses feelings and independence.
Memory code: "W-R-T = D-N-E" in the same order: Williamson = Directive, Rogers = Non-directive, Thorne = Eclectic. Lead in the counsellor's hands = directive; in the client's hands = non-directive; shared between the two = eclectic.