Rabindranath was a man of many talents; he became world famous with the Nobel Prize for his book "Gitanjali". In every object of nature around him he could see not only poetic inspiration but God himself. Jiddu Krishnamurti tried hard to reform this world, full of crises and problems such as poverty, hatred, narrow-mindedness, violence and jealousy. He gave mankind a new kind of thinking: that man should become completely free, free from all bonds.
Rabindranath Tagore: ideas
- Rabindranath Tagore was a philosopher, poet, playwright and novelist. Indianness was his very breath. His bond with nature was unmatched.
- The spiritual unity of mankind was his heart's wish. Tagore's humanism had no limits. He was a prophet who taught that world unity is the supreme goal.
- Tagore's book "Gitanjali" won the Nobel Prize in 1913.
- He recognised man's inseparable bond with nature. That is why he wished that study should take place in the midst of nature. Through his own initiative the pupil builds his acquaintance with nature by himself.
- Rabindranath held that children's natural senses should not be spoiled in the artificial atmosphere of the town. Every particle of nature gives man endless things; so his argument was that the child should not be kept away from nature.
- In this way physical and mental powers grow through natural, spontaneous activity without artificial stimuli. Children love natural life most. If they are made to love natural life, they will devote their very lives to gaining knowledge.
- Rabindranath's humanist outlook had no borders. "Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam" (the world is one family) was his goal. He held that there should be no walls between East and West.
- That is why he shaped "Visva-Bharati" as an international university, giving admission to all without distinction of sex, caste, religion, or home or foreign country.
Tagore: philosophy of education
- He criticised schools for teaching in a mechanical way that keeps pupils captive within four walls.
- Disliking study in the cramped rooms of school, he stopped going to school in his childhood. He felt that the education in the schools of that time was useless.
- He wished that educational institutions would work to shape a person's life. He grieved that schools gave only information and knowledge but neglected what concerns human growth.
Philosophy of education - main principles:
- All-round development: physical, intellectual, moral and spiritual development.
- Brotherhood, international understanding, development of the universal man.
- Giving the pupil a complete life: it is the school's responsibility to give a complete life in natural surroundings, not in a fake (artificial) atmosphere.
- Education through a natural process: a child's subconscious mind is more active than the conscious intellect. Children learn many things through the subconscious mind without getting tired. He held that children should not be forced to learn what is in textbooks; they should be made to learn in natural surroundings.
- He thought that, for the all-round development of pupils, learning should take place through activities on physical exercise, games, songs, drawing, agriculture, gardening, educational tours, regional studies, experimental activities, social service and self-government.
- Teaching methods: field trips, teaching while walking, educational tours, observation, discussion, debate, the heuristic method, teaching through activities. Tired of the mechanical system of education, he held that today's education system is crippled because of the lack of proper teaching.
- Discipline: he held that discipline is possible only when pupils learn by themselves through lively learning. He believed that active programmes such as games, songs and jumping give physical exercise along with proper mental and physical training.
- Teacher: the guru should play the most prominent role. As a committed guide, he should teach in real situations so that children merge freely with nature. Tagore gave importance to all kinds of activity, such as climbing trees and roaming in the mud. Lively learning gives children full results.
Visva-Bharati
Reflecting the noble Indian ideals, with no room for caste or religion, the pillars of universal human brotherhood and "the world is one family" founded "Visva-Bharati".
| Branch | Department |
|---|---|
| Shishu Bhavan | Nursery section |
| Vidya Bhavan | Research centre |
| Adhyapak Shiksha Bhavan | Teacher training college |
| Kala Bhavan | Training in music and dance |
| Sriniketan | Rural development institute |
| Shilpa Bhavan | Industrial training |
| Vinaya Bhavan | Teacher training department |
| Cheena Bhavan | Department of Chinese and Tibetan languages |
- All the classes at Visva-Bharati are held in the open air, in the shade of trees. The main aim of this university is to develop personality from every side.
Jiddu Krishnamurti: philosophical ideas
- A modern Indian philosopher. An important chapter of his life began when Annie Besant, founder of the Theosophical Society, adopted him.
- In keeping with his ideas and ideals, one school was started at Rishi Valley in Madanapalle and another at Rajghat in Varanasi.
- He held that teacher and pupil are all equal; all are seekers of truth.
Jiddu Krishnamurti: ideas on education
- Education should give the pupil complete freedom.
- Teaching should take place in an atmosphere of freedom. The time a pupil spends at school should be joyful.
- Knowledge is the pupil knowing himself.
- Knowledge comes from the constant search for truth.
- Creativity should be built in pupils.
- Creativity means having inner inspiration.
- The search for truth and creativity need freedom; freedom needs wisdom (discernment).
- The idea is to make a member of the global village, a member of the one world family.
- He longed for a universal human family without distinction of caste, religion, race or colour.
- He held that in the world no one is anyone's guru; all are equal.
- The mind has the power to think; the wise man is the one who can use it to find the truth.
- There should be no room for fear in pupils; they should follow non-violence in life.
- Pupils should know their powers, abilities and weaknesses and blossom fully with their mental powers. The teacher's ideas should not be forced on them.
- Education is not reading books or earning degrees; it should help one observe and enjoy the beauty of nature and gain knowledge.
- A job should not be the goal of education. Education should not be a mechanical process.
- Pupils also need spiritual training.
Teachers:
- Teachers should not feel that they are great; they should feel that all are seekers of truth. They should be friendly towards pupils and devoted to their profession. They should behave knowing that teachers too are lifelong learners.
- They should take up the responsibility of making pupils complete human beings; in discipline they should use the method of self-discipline.
- Teachers should not become a problem for pupils; that is why teachers need training.
- In Krishnamurti's view, life is one complete whole; it is indivisible. Education should work for the wholeness of the person. It should make freedom, love and goodness blossom in them.
- His idea was that the building of a good society is possible only through education.
| Point | Tagore | Jiddu Krishnamurti |
|---|---|---|
| Main idea | Education in the midst of nature; world unity | Complete freedom; knowing oneself is knowledge |
| Institutions | Visva-Bharati (international university) | Rishi Valley (Madanapalle), Rajghat (Varanasi) |
| The guru | A guide who helps the child merge with nature | No one is anyone's guru; all are seekers of truth |
| Criticism | Mechanical education within four walls | Mechanical education with a job as its goal |
| Common ground | The world is one family, the universal man | The world is one family, a member of the global village |
Exam focus: Tagore = Gitanjali, Nobel 1913; education in the midst of nature; criticism of mechanical education within four walls; the subconscious mind; the world is one family; Visva-Bharati = international university, classes in the shade of trees; Sriniketan = rural development; Shishu Bhavan = nursery; Kala Bhavan = music and dance. Krishnamurti = adopted by Annie Besant; Rishi Valley (Madanapalle), Rajghat (Varanasi); complete freedom; no one is anyone's guru; a job should not be the goal of education.
Memory code: "G-N-13" - Gitanjali, Nobel, 1913. Visva-Bharati branches "S-V-K-S": Shishu Bhavan = nursery, Vidya Bhavan = research, Kala Bhavan = music and dance, Sriniketan = rural development. "Jiddu = R-R" - Rishi Valley, Rajghat; "F needs W": Freedom needs Wisdom.