Language teaching and teaching methods
- Children use language often in various activities and daily tasks (such as shopping). When Telugu is used as a second language, second-language learning at school is needed to learn cognitive and language skills.
- Reading, writing, learning and understanding content are possible only through language. If second-language learning happens naturally / through the mother tongue, children can learn more.
- The idea that children naturally learn whatever language is used in class is not true. Deaf children communicate through lip reading or through writing.
- Language should be learnt practically, by seeing it in daily life and using words. But in schools, teachers use old methods and depend only on talk; they confuse children with meaningless words and instructions. Not knowing the difference between everyday spoken language and colloquial language, students get confused; developing reading and writing in the second language becomes hard.
The three-language formula
- The three-language formula for school education was proposed by the Central Advisory Board of Education (CABE) in 1956. It was modified at a conference of ministers in 1961. The Kothari Commission supported it for these reasons:
- Recognising the rights of minority groups, teaching should happen in their mother tongues.
- Treating the official language of the state as the regional language helps social and cultural unity.
- Under the three-language formula, three languages must be learnt.
| Language | Hindi-speaking states | Non-Hindi-speaking states |
|---|---|---|
| First language | Mother tongue or regional language | Mother tongue or regional language |
| Second language | Any modern Indian language or English | Hindi or English |
| Third language | English | - |
- Implementation: mother-tongue teaching from Class 1; the second language from Class 6 or Class 3 depending on the state's resources; the third language should also be taught from Class 6. At present English is taught from Class 1 itself.
- Policy: although the government often says which language should be used in education, every community encourages communication in a common language. One language is needed to express nationhood and for the country's economic affairs. There are many such problems in framing policy for teaching and for conducting examinations.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
భారతదేశంలోని అన్ని రాష్ట్రాల వారు మూడు భాషలు నేర్చుకోవాలన్న విధానం
- (1)త్రిభాషా సూత్రం
- (2)ద్విభాషా సూత్రం
- (3)ప్రథమభాషా సూత్రం
- (4)మాతృభాషా సూత్రం
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (1) త్రిభాషా సూత్రం
The question asks the name of the language policy under which people of all states in India learn three languages.
On the recommendation of the Kothari Commission (1964-66), the National Policy on Education 1968 adopted the Three Language Formula (త్రిభాషా సూత్రం): the mother tongue or regional language, Hindi and English; in Hindi-speaking states, Hindi, English and another modern Indian language. NEP 2020 also continues it. So the answer is option (1) త్రిభాషా సూత్రం.
ద్విభాషా సూత్రం (2) means two languages only. ప్రథమభాషా సూత్రం (3) and మాతృభాషా సూత్రం (4) focus on a single language; the mother tongue is only one part of the three-language formula. The word త్రి itself means three.
Remember: త్రి = three: Kothari Commission, NPE 1968.
Teachers, community and materials
- Recruitment and training of teachers: in some cases teachers do not let children speak their home language in class; making them speak only the official language suppresses the home / regional language. It is hard to recruit teachers who know the languages of minority communities; so students from weaker sections should be given a place in teacher training courses. Teachers are mostly trained in the English medium; this supports the teaching of English.
- Participation of the community and parents: there is a gap between the learner's home environment and school experiences. Family members do not speak the language the child is learning. If this gap narrows, it supports learning.
- Script policies and curriculum materials: teachers do not encourage speaking in the regional language; materials are not available in the mother tongue; so curricular progress drops. Language should be practised continuously. Multilingual education can be given along with the mother tongue. Decision-makers should design curriculum materials that meet the needs of a multilingual society.
- Understanding the child's abilities: by the time the child comes to school he has already learnt the language around him; he builds language and cognitive skills without training. But the school does not recognise the child's mother tongue; school learning has no link with home language experiences. So teachers should listen to what students say.
Aims of language teaching and language pedagogy
- The aims of language teaching: Listening, Speaking, Reading, Writing (LSRW). Along with these, other language abilities should be developed cognitively and artistically.
- Basic interpersonal communication skills should be built in students. Children can be given experiences by creating conversation situations, texts related to writing and a variety of situations.
- Language pedagogy: which teaching method to choose depends on the nature of the content, the nature of the language, the child's cognitive development and the learning process.
- All subject classes and language classes at school are important. In grasping language, every subject has its own vocabulary and concepts; language development in schools is often incomplete. If language is not learnt properly, children fall behind in other subjects too.
- Language should not be limited to one book; language experiences should be given through literature as well as the textbook.
Reading, writing and learning through reading
- Literacy is very important at the primary stage; but at the primary school level it has been largely neglected. Good reading and writing skills are needed for language development and for self-learning.
- For writing, forming letters and punctuation marks are important. Arranging thoughts in a form is the key to writing. Reading and writing should be learnt at the primary stage itself with the right teaching methods; guidance should be given while correcting faults in learning attitude.
- Learning through reading: if reading and writing get priority at the primary level, these skills serve personal learning needs in later stages.
- At the school stage, along with narrative texts, expository (non-fiction) texts should also get priority. With narrative texts children read for pleasure and build self-confidence.
- In higher classes students write answers to questions, but the thinking process does not grow much; arranging ideas and writing independently does not develop. So only a few grow into independent learners with language abilities.
Exam focus: Three-language formula - proposed by CABE 1956, modified at the 1961 conference of ministers, supported by the Kothari Commission. First language = mother tongue / regional language. Aims of language teaching LSRW (listening, speaking, reading, writing). Deaf children communicate through lip reading / writing.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
Expand LSRW
- (1)Learning, Serving, Remembering, Watching
- (2)Listening, Speaking, Reading, Writing
- (3)Laughing, Selecting, Reaching, Working
- (4)Lecturing, Signing, Relaxing, Worshipping
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (2) Listening, Speaking, Reading, Writing
The question asks what the abbreviation LSRW stands for.
Language teaching is built on four basic skills: Listening, Speaking, Reading and Writing. A child learns language in this same order: first listening and understanding, then speaking, then reading and finally writing. Listening and reading are receptive skills; speaking and writing are productive (expressive) skills.
So the answer is option (2), Listening, Speaking, Reading, Writing.
The words in options (1), (3) and (4) begin with the same letters, but they are not language skills. In language teaching LSRW always means these four skills.
Remember: LSRW is also the natural order of learning a language.
Teaching to children by following the sequence is acceptable
- (1)Reading – Writing – Listening - Speaking
- (2)Listening – Speaking – Reading - Writing
- (3)Speaking – Listening – Writing - Reading
- (4)Writing – Reading – Speaking - Listening
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (2) Listening – Speaking – Reading - Writing
The question asks the right order in which language skills should be taught to children.
Children learn their mother tongue naturally in this order: they first listen, then speak what they hear, then learn to read letters and words, and finally write. This is the LSRW order. Listening and reading are receptive skills; speaking and writing are productive skills. Teaching should follow this natural order.
So the answer is option (2), Listening – Speaking – Reading - Writing.
Options (1) and (4) start with reading or writing, but a child who has not yet heard and spoken the language cannot make sense of written symbols. Option (3) starts with speaking, which is not possible without listening first, and it also puts writing before reading.
Remember: LSRW: Listen, Speak, Read, Write.
Memory code: "56 proposed, 61 modified" - CABE 1956, conference of ministers 1961. The order of the three languages "M-H-E" - Mother tongue, Hindi (or a modern Indian language), English. The LSRW order "L-S-R-W" - Listening, Speaking, Reading, Writing.