In India, education is everyone's right. Many commissions were set up to improve the state of education. Even so, secondary, senior secondary and college education have problems such as a faulty examination system and poor quality. Primary education should come first and secondary education next; our Constitution too gave importance to both. We need an education system that serves the progress and welfare of society and is useful to future generations.
Changes in education across the world
Educationists who analysed the changes in education systems across the world pointed out these features:
- Changing technology is affecting information and communication technology.
- Importance for self-learning, self-directed learning and cooperative learning.
- Building facilities of schools and institutions.
- Matters related to professional development.
- The Delors Commission report "Learning: The Treasure Within" described the new trends in education across the world and laid down various standards. It said education is necessary for culture and for progress.
- Mahatma Gandhi said that education is needed for a healthy nation. Through education, physical, mental and spiritual development of the child is possible. Along with globalisation, teaching and learning methods must also change.
- The National Policy on Education 1986 (NPE) created the 10+2+3 pattern at the national level: 10 years of general education, 2 years of secondary education and a 3-year degree course.
- In the first 10 years the student should gain language proficiency and knowledge of mathematics, geography, and political and economic matters. Only after that comes university or college education.
- The present challenge: teaching is confined to the four walls of the classroom. The teacher only gives information and prepares students for examinations. Students do not take part in learning; unable to plan their future, they become dissatisfied.
Problems in secondary and higher education
| Problem | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Unrest | Problems in the atmosphere of colleges and schools, bandhs and protests |
| Syllabus and funds | No changes in the syllabus; about 95% of the funds are spent only on teachers' salaries and allowances, laboratories, playgrounds and other facilities |
| Lack of vocational opportunities | The government could not provide the materials and teachers needed for vocational education |
| Only book knowledge | Secondary education is theoretical and limited to books; it is not useful for social life; it should build job opportunities, self-reliance and patriotism |
| No productivity | Unlike in Western countries, it does not raise productivity in the country's agricultural and industrial sectors |
| No national development | It does not support the country's economic development and national development; it does not train human resources; it should use natural resources well and support technical and industrial development |
| No all-round development | It does not support the all-round development of the individual in adolescence |
| Weak character training | Little training in values such as cooperation, honesty, respect for teachers and elders, and brotherhood towards the nation and culture |
| Curriculum | Almost the same everywhere; does not reflect individual and social needs; no practical experiences |
| Teaching methods | Teachers use stereotyped methods; they do not use new activity-based methods; laboratories, teaching aids and libraries are not enough |
| Textbooks | Change often; high prices; not available to everyone |
| Financial shortage | Many schools lack proper financial resources; government schools are few; private schools also face a shortage of funds |
- Before independence, secondary education served only to provide job opportunities. Though many commissions and committees came before and after independence, secondary institutions could not reach those aims.
- The Mudaliar Commission (1952-53) and the Kothari Commission (1964-66) asked for secondary education to raise productivity. But that aim was not fulfilled. The scheme brought in for work experience did not give results; vocational opportunities did not grow at the 10+2 level.
- These two commissions suggested changing the secondary curriculum to make it useful for everyone; the results were not as expected.
- The secondary curriculum gives more importance to academic matters; vocational matters get importance only after +2, at the university level.
- Patriotism, dedication, democratic qualities and qualities of citizenship should be built in students. The present system does not build social competencies; if the social side of education is neglected, social development does not happen.
- Education and culture are not the same idea; culture is wider than education. Secondary education should combine traditional customs with new cultures.
- Since today's students are tomorrow's leaders, leadership training should be given at the secondary stage through co-curricular activities.
Examinations, teachers and administration
- With proper examination methods, the education system can be made more scientific and reliable. Along with essay-type examinations, other methods should also be used in a research-minded way.
- The Radhakrishnan Commission and the Hartog, Mudaliar and Kothari commissions examined the examination system and suggested:
- Along with the external examination there should be internal assessment; teachers should test throughout the year, and a test can even be held once every two weeks.
- A grading system should be used instead of percentages.
- Besides essay questions, the question paper should have objective questions worth 30% of the total marks.
- Teacher training programmes are not enough. Teaching is a complex task and an art; a degree alone does not make a good teacher. Dedicated teachers are few; many secondary teachers have no training.
- In-service training is needed for professional growth: refresher courses during the summer holidays, in-service courses, workshops, seminars and conferences.
- Administration is weak: it works at the Central, State and district levels. Although the States run secondary education, the Centre frames one policy for the whole country; implementation is in the hands of the State education department.
- State board: curriculum, books and the examination system. Education department: general policies, allotment of funds and professional training for teachers. Because of this dual control and the lack of cooperation among officials, the aims of secondary education are not being met.
- Because political parties split students into factions, non-academic activities grow and the academic atmosphere in schools is damaged.
- Secondary education should be based on the student's abilities, attitudes and interests; the curriculum should have variety to meet the aspirations of adolescents.
- After independence, secondary education expanded greatly; it raises the minimum learning levels of students. Even so, secondary education opportunities for children aged 14-18 years must grow further. Those who complete primary education do not get admission because of a shortage of facilities; admission should be given to all without any selective admission process.
- Secondary education has not yet been nationalised; the standards of schools differ; unrecognised schools, shortage of funds, shortage of furniture and enrolment problems are lowering quality.
Exam focus: 10+2+3 = NPE 1986 (10 general + 2 secondary + 3 degree). Mudaliar Commission 1952-53, Kothari Commission 1964-66. Examination reforms: internal assessment, grades, 30% objective questions. State board + education department = dual control. About 95% of funds go only on salaries and facilities.
Memory code: "Mu-Ko = 52-64" - Mudaliar 1952-53, Kothari 1964-66. Examination reforms "I-G-30" - Internal assessment, Grades, 30% objective questions.