Why does the functional definition matter?
- Society treats a person according to the "label" we give. For example: a person with visual acuity of 2/60 may have sight that is useful for movement. But once labelled "blind", he is treated as totally blind; the sight he has is ignored.
- That is why there must be a difference between legal blindness and functional blindness / low vision.
- People with visual impairment are classified in two ways: (1) medical classification (based on acuity and field), (2) educational classification (based on the ability to learn).
WHO categories 0-5: three definitions compared
Based on visual acuity in the better eye after best correction:
| Category | Visual acuity (better eye) | WHO standard definition | Working definition | India (old) definition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 6/6 to 6/18 | Normal | Normal | Normal |
| 1 | Less than 6/18 to 6/60 | Moderate visual impairment | Low vision | Low vision |
| 2 | Less than 6/60 to 3/60 | Severe visual impairment | Low vision | Blindness |
| 3 | Less than 3/60 to 1/60 | Blindness | Low vision | Blindness |
| 4 | Less than 1/60 to light perception (PL) | Blindness | Low vision | Blindness |
| 5 | No light perception (NPL) | Blindness | Total blindness | Total blindness |
- WHO standard definition: less than 3/60 in the better eye = blindness (categories 3, 4, 5). India's old definition calls it blindness from 6/60 itself.
- WHO working (functional) definition: as long as there is light perception, usable sight is assumed to be present; only when even light cannot be seen is it blindness.
- So a person whose acuity is better than 3/60 but equal to or less than 6/60 is called "blind" by India (old definition) and "low vision" by WHO.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
The visual acuity of a normal individual is
- (1)20/20
- (2)20/100
- (3)20/200
- (4)20/70
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (1) 20/20
The question asks for the visual acuity of a person with normal eyesight.
Visual acuity is measured with a Snellen chart read from 20 feet. The top number is the testing distance (20 feet). The bottom number is the distance from which a normal eye can read the same letters. 20/20 means the person reads at 20 feet what a normal eye reads at 20 feet, so vision is normal. In metres it is written 6/6.
So the answer is option (1), 20/20.
20/70 (4) means the person must come to 20 feet to read what a normal eye reads from 70 feet; this is where low vision begins. 20/100 (2) is poorer vision still. 20/200 (3) is the level counted as blindness. The larger the bottom number, the poorer the vision.
Remember: 20/20 (6/6) = normal; bigger bottom number = poorer vision.
A person with visual acuity of 6/6 has
- (1)Low vision
- (2)Total Blindness
- (3)Normal vision
- (4)Partial blindness
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (3) Normal vision
The question asks what a visual acuity of 6/6 means.
Visual acuity is tested with a Snellen chart from a distance of 6 metres. The top number is the testing distance (6 m); the bottom number is the distance from which a person with normal vision can read the same line. 6/6 means the person reads at 6 metres what a normal person reads at 6 metres, so the vision is normal.
So the answer is option (3) Normal vision.
Under the RPwD Act 2016, visual acuity worse than 6/18 down to 3/60 in the better eye with best correction is low vision (1), and worse than 3/60 is blindness. Total blindness (2) means no sight at all, and partial blindness (4) is also reduced sight. A 6/6 acuity fits none of these.
Remember: 6/6 = normal vision; the bigger the bottom number, the poorer the sight.
Why did experts argue that India should keep 6/60?
- In India, those with acuity not exceeding 6/60 (6/60 or worse) are legally blind. Because of this they receive certain services and financial benefits. Even though legally blind, many of them have functional sight that lets them do some tasks.
- At the time of the PWD Act 1995, the experts' argument was this:
- If blindness were limited to "light perception to no light perception", many people who now receive benefits such as railway concessions and scholarships (which were already very few) would lose eligibility.
- On the other hand, if concessions were given to everyone with low vision from 6/18 down to light perception, the government might not be able to bear that demand financially.
- So for developing countries like India they suggested keeping 6/60 (20/200) or less, or a field of 20 degrees or less = blindness; 6/18 to 6/60 (20/60 to 20/200) = low vision.
- Later the RPwD Act 2016 changed blindness, as WHO does, to 3/60 and 10 degrees (see the table of definitions above).
Levels of visual impairment in feet
In the better eye with best spectacle correction:
| Acuity (in feet) | Level |
|---|---|
| 20/30 to 20/60 | Mild vision loss / near-normal vision |
| 20/70 to 20/160 | Moderate visual impairment / moderate low vision |
| 20/200 to 20/400 | Severe visual impairment / severe low vision |
| 20/500 to 20/1000 | Profound visual impairment / profound low vision |
| Less than 20/1000 | Near-total visual impairment / near-total blindness |
| No light perception | Total visual impairment / total blindness |
- In metres 3/60 = 20/400 in feet; 6/60 = 20/200; 6/18 = 20/60.
Disability percentage categories in the old Indian guidelines
At the time of the PWD Act 1995, these categories were used to decide the percentage of visual disability (after the RPwD Act 2016, new guidelines replaced them):
| Category | Better eye | Worse eye | Disability percentage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Category 0 | 6/9 to 6/18 | 6/24 to 6/36 | 20% |
| Category 1 | 6/18 to 6/36 | 6/60 to nil | 40% |
| Category 2 | 6/40 to 4/60, or field 10-20 degrees | 3/60 to nil | 75% |
| Category 3 | 3/60 to 1/60, or field 10 degrees | Finger counting at 1 foot to nil | 100% |
| Category 4 | Finger counting at 1 foot to nil, or field 10 degrees | Finger counting at 1 foot to nil | 100% |
| One-eyed persons | 6/6 | Finger counting at 1 foot to nil, or field 10 degrees | 30% |
- Those with 20% to 40% disability must use visual aids.
Other categories and terms
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Partially sighted | For educational purposes: (1) students with acuity of 20/70 or less in the better eye after best correction who can use sight as their main channel of learning; (2) students who, in the opinion of an eye specialist and education officials, benefit from the special facilities arranged for partially sighted students. Because they need large-print books, they are also called "print-disabled" |
| One-eyed persons | The Indian definition of blindness does not treat a person with a defect in only one eye as blind. A person with one good eye is not blind. Their disability is only 30%; usually a disability certificate is given only for 40% or more |
| Monocular visual impairment | Seeing with the sight of only one eye; since there is no two-eyed (binocular) vision, depth perception is limited |
| Vision loss | Everyone who has difficulty seeing even with spectacles / contact lenses, and those who cannot see at all |
| Self-reported vision loss | Decided on the basis of what a person reports about his or her own sight and its effect on daily tasks |
| Functional limitation | The link between visual functioning and the ability to do daily tasks. The tasks most affected: reading, walking safely, self-care, cooking, leisure activities |
| Legal blindness | The level of vision loss defined by law for eligibility for benefits: central acuity of 20/200 or less in the better eye with best correction, and / or a field of 20 degrees or less. Many of them still have some usable sight |
| Total blindness | A state in which nothing can be seen with either eye |
- Other factors that affect visual impairment: contrast sensitivity, light sensitivity, glare sensitivity, and the ability to adapt to light and dark.
Central scotoma and tunnel vision
| Defect | What happens | Causes |
|---|---|---|
| Central scotoma | A blurred or black hole is seen in the centre of objects; side vision remains | Macular degeneration, optic atrophy (wasting of the optic nerve) |
| Tunnel vision | Side (peripheral) vision is lost and the visual field becomes narrow; objects in the centre are seen | Glaucoma, retinitis pigmentosa (RP) |
Educational classification
| Level | Ability |
|---|---|
| Mild / moderate visual impairment | Can do class work almost like an ordinary student with some special aids |
| Severe visual impairment | Find it hard to see even in proper light and cannot do tasks; but learning with visual aids, and the use of sight after medical treatment, improve |
| Profound visual impairment | Cannot do any task properly with sight; do educational activities through hearing and touch |
Prevalence: in the world
- WHO estimate (2010 figures): about 285 million people in the world have visual impairment. Of them, 39 million are blind and 246 million have low vision.
- 82% of the blind are aged over 50.
- About 90% of the world's blind live in developing countries.
- According to the WHO and World Bank "World Report on Disability 2011", about 15% of the world's population has some disability. As life expectancy rises, age-related problems such as cataract are increasing.
- The WHO programme "Vision 2020: The Right to Sight" (1999) worked with the aim of eliminating avoidable blindness by 2020. WHO helps countries expand eye-health services and increase rehabilitation centres for people with residual vision.
Prevalence: census figures in India
- Accurate population figures are needed to plan, implement and evaluate welfare schemes for people with disabilities. They come from the census and NSSO surveys.
- NSSO (National Sample Survey Organisation, now the National Sample Survey Office): set up in 1950; works under the Union Ministry of Statistics; the largest organisation conducting regular socio-economic surveys in the country.
Census 2001 (information on 5 types of disability):
| Item | Number | Percentage of population |
|---|---|---|
| Total population | 1,028,610,328 | 100 |
| Persons with disability | 21,906,769 (about 2.19 crore) | 2.1 |
| Visual disability | 10,634,881 | 1.0 |
| Movement (locomotor) disability | 6,105,477 | 0.6 |
| Mental disability | 2,263,821 | 0.2 |
| Speech disability | 1,640,868 | 0.2 |
| Hearing disability | 1,261,722 | 0.1 |
- Among persons with disability, visual disability is first at 48.5%. Next: movement 27.9%, mental 10.3%, speech 7.5%, hearing 5.8%.
- Among persons with disability, males 1.26 crore, females 93 lakh. The disability rate is 2,130 per lakh population (males 2,369, females 1,874).
- Women's share is higher in visual and hearing disabilities. The largest number of persons with disability is in Uttar Pradesh (about 34.5 lakh).
Census 2011 (India's 15th census; held in two phases):
- Persons with disability 26,810,557 (about 2.68 crore) - 2.21% of the population.
- Persons with visual disability 5,032,463 - about 18.8% of persons with disability.
- In 2011 information on 8 types of disability was collected (only 5 types in 2001). Because the categories and questions changed, the 2001 and 2011 percentages cannot be compared directly.
Causes of blindness in India
National Programme for Control of Blindness (NPCB) survey 2001-02:
| Cause | Share of blindness |
|---|---|
| Cataract | 62.6% |
| Refractive errors | 19.7% |
| Glaucoma | 5.8% |
| Diseases of the back of the eye (retina-related) | 4.7% |
| Corneal diseases | 0.9% |
| The rest | Other causes |
- According to the National Blindness and Visual Impairment Survey 2015-19, cataract causes 66.2% of blindness among those aged over 50. About 93% of blindness in that age group is avoidable.
- So the main cause of blindness in India is cataract.
- Blindness in children: 0.8 per 1,000 children.
- In rural areas, lack of awareness, malnutrition and poor personal hygiene are major causes of blindness. Many eye diseases give no early warning such as pain or a change in sight; that is why regular eye check-ups are needed.
Exam focus: WHO categories: 0 normal (6/6-6/18); 1, 2 visual impairment; 3, 4, 5 blindness (less than 3/60); 5 = NPL. India's old definition counts blindness from 6/60. 3/60 = 20/400, 6/60 = 20/200. Percentages of the old Indian categories: 20, 40, 75, 100, 100; one eye = 30% (not blindness). Partially sighted = 20/70 or less. Central scotoma = macular degeneration, optic atrophy; tunnel vision = glaucoma, retinitis pigmentosa. Census 2001: 2.19 crore (2.1%), visual 48.5% (first place). Census 2011: 2.68 crore (2.21%), visual 18.8%, 8 types. WHO 2010: 285 / 39 / 246 million. Main cause of blindness in India is cataract (62.6%; 66.2% in the 2015-19 survey).
Memory code: WHO categories "0 fine, 1-2 impaired, 3-4-5 blind". Old Indian percentages "20-40-75-100-100, one eye 30". Scotoma and tunnel "Middle spot = Macula; Edges lost = Glaucoma, RP". Census "2001 = 48.5 (nearly half visual), 2011 = 18.8". WHO "285 = 39 + 246". Indian causes "C-R-G" - Cataract 62.6, Refractive errors 19.7, Glaucoma 5.8.