Ever since the education of the blind began, good teachers have been practising these principles even without knowing the theory. Special teaching is very important for blind and visually impaired students to understand the concepts of the visual world - because natural (incidental) learning experiences do not reach them; they cannot observe objects and interactions.
Berthold Lowenfeld gave three main principles / strategies for teaching students with visual impairment: (1) concrete (direct) experiences, (2) unified experiences, (3) learning by doing. Some educators add three more: individualisation, additional stimulation and self-activity.
Educational setup
How far these principles are carried out depends on where the child studies - in a group in a residential school set up to suit their needs, or alone in a regular school (where there must be an understanding regular teacher and a resource or itinerant teacher). The type of educational setup changes the teacher's role.
1. The need for concrete experiences
- To make up to some extent for the limitation in the range and variety of experiences, the teacher must give varied concrete experiences.
- It is not important for the blind child to learn concretely about rare, exotic objects; his basic need is to learn about his own surroundings.
- The deep, basic needs of blind children: rich, close experience with ordinary objects; direct acquaintance with the many people seen in daily life and their activities. Words are no substitute for these; direct contact with the world is needed. (A passive, sitting-down tendency is not their need.)
- Concreteness comes in two ways: examining the real object / situation, or giving its model. As far as possible, preference goes to the real thing. Enough time must be given for examining.
- Educational excursions and field trips introduce situations that would otherwise stay abstract.
- A model is only a substitute; unless its size and other distortions are fully explained to the student, it is incomplete and distorted.
- Example: to learn about an animal or a vehicle, direct experience gives its smell, feel, shape and size by first-hand touch. Real bones to teach about the skeleton; walking to the library for the concept of a library.
- Embossed pictures: they have been tried many times as equivalents of visual pictures, but without lasting success. Blind children can recognise line drawings of almost two-dimensional objects such as a leaf, a fork or a butterfly; they understand a human figure by comparing it with their own body. But a picture of an animal drawn with three legs, because the fourth leg is not seen, gives a wrong idea. Even so, despite the limitations, line drawings and embossed maps are very valuable from the early classes in teaching spatial concepts and the relationships needed for orientation.
- Giving knowledge of facts does not mean enlarging vocabulary; it means giving a sense of the reality of the surroundings. This keeps the child from slipping into an unreal tendency, and helps him take an active part in conversations with others without falling behind.
- Concepts such as temperature, distance and weight are learnt well through direct sensory experiences.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
Embossed diagrams are used to teach for children with
- (1)Autism spectrum disorder
- (2)Down's syndrome
- (3)Visual Impairment
- (4)Thalasemia
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (3) Visual Impairment
The question asks which children are taught with embossed diagrams.
In an embossed diagram the lines and shapes are raised above the paper. A child who cannot see feels the shape with the fingers and understands it through touch. Like Braille, this tactile material is a key TLM for children with visual impairment.
So the answer is option (3), Visual Impairment.
Children with autism (1) benefit more from visual schedules and picture cards. Children with Down's syndrome (2) need simple, concrete material, but they can see. Thalassemia (4) is a blood disorder and does not call for tactile teaching material.
Remember: Material to be felt with the fingers = visual impairment.
Concepts of temperature, distance and weight can be learnt better by children with special needs through
- (1)Visual experiences
- (2)Direct sensory experiences
- (3)Audio logical experiences
- (4)Reading experiences
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (2) Direct sensory experiences
The question asks what helps children with special needs learn concepts like temperature, distance and weight. The answer is option (2), Direct sensory experiences.
Hot and cold are known by touching, weight by lifting, and distance by walking it. These concepts are experienced directly through the senses. Direct sensory experience means children learn by touching, lifting, walking and doing. In Edgar Dale's Cone of Experience, direct experiences sit at the base as the most effective.
Visual experiences do not work for a child with visual impairment, and audio experiences do not work for a child with hearing impairment. Reading is the most abstract and is hard for children with reading difficulties. Also, warmth or weight cannot be fully understood by only seeing, hearing or reading. So options (1), (3) and (4) are wrong.
Remember: Touch it, lift it, do it: that is direct sensory experience.
2. The need for unified experiences
- Blind children are at a serious disadvantage in experiencing objects and situations as wholes. Touch lets them examine at one time only the objects they can hold with their hands or body. Large objects can be examined only through successive touch movements, and often only some parts of them.
- Sight unifies observations; it organises the separate impressions coming from the other senses.
- To make up for this, the teacher must give chances to experience situations as wholes; experiences of parts must be joined into a meaningful whole.
- The main tool for this is teaching by study units. Through it students learn not only the facts but also how the separate parts come together to form the whole object, situation or topic.
- When a task is broken into small steps (task analysis), the steps must later be joined and practised again as one whole routine, so that the child gets a unified experience.
3. The need for learning by doing
- Because of blindness, and the surroundings' response to it, blind children get very few chances to do things themselves.
- From early childhood there is no visual motivation to watch and imitate others' activities, and many parents tend to stop at meeting the child's bodily needs - these two together create a tendency towards inertia in blind children.
- They must be encouraged to learn to do things themselves with as little help as possible: eating, dressing, playing, meeting people, moving about. The more situations they learn to handle, the greater their sense of security and the more positive their self-concept.
- Some tasks must be learnt without depending on sight - cooking food, housework and daily routines are very important for the blind.
- Unnecessary kindness, pity, compassion and giving others priority create helplessness. Persons with disabilities should be encouraged to help themselves, and their responsibilities should be increased.
- In creative activities, teachers must not force their "sighted taste" on blind children. The visual form of a clay model is irrelevant to the blind child; he expresses tactile concepts. The result may not look like the object to the eye; the process matters, not the product.
Teacher-pupil ratio
- For all this individual attention to be possible, the number of children with a teacher must be small - whether in a residential school or in a local school with a resource / itinerant teacher.
- The number depends on the class level, age, subject (in higher classes) and geographical location (for itinerant teachers). Usually 5 to 10 children per teacher.
- When an itinerant teacher serves blind children of the primary classes, or when children have multiple disabilities (VIMD), the ratio must be very low - sometimes one to one (1 : 1).
More points to remember in teaching
- The age at which blindness began is most crucial.
- How much residual vision there is decides the nature and strength of visual images.
- Whether the residual vision is stable, and whether there is psychological trauma, must be checked.
- The family background must be known.
- Concrete life situations must be created to give the experiences missed in daily life.
- For experiences not found at home or in class, the child must be taken outside when needed.
- Models must be used only when unavoidable.
- Visits to museums, post offices, markets and socio-cultural centres must be arranged.
- Touching objects must not be forbidden; it must be encouraged.
- As far as possible, verbal explanation must be backed by concrete experiences.
- Reward and punishment must be used with judgement to motivate wide contact with the surroundings.
- Line drawings in Braille or in large print must be used for a sense of the three-dimensional world along with the two-dimensional.
- Learning by doing must be the teacher's basic principle - images and concepts form through it.
- Play must be used widely at home and in class as a tool of cognitive development.
- Acting must be used in suitable situations to improve expression and strengthen memory and recall.
- Role play must be used to give experience of life situations.
Exam focus: Lowenfeld's teaching principles are three: concrete experiences, unified experiences, learning by doing. Preference to the real object; a model only when unavoidable. The limitation of embossed pictures - the three-legged animal. The tool for unified experiences - teaching by study units. The cause of inertia - no motivation to imitate + parents who stop at bodily needs. In creative work the process matters. Ratio 5-10; 1 : 1 for VIMD. Touching must be encouraged.
Memory code: Lowenfeld's teaching principles "C-U-D" - "the blind child must chew the CUD of experience": Concrete experiences, Unified experiences, learning by Doing. Ratio "5-10, 1 for multiple".