Any interaction with the surroundings needs information to be collected, stored, retrieved and organised. The absence of sight limits this process. How big this gap is, and how much of it closes as age and experience grow, can be understood through Piaget's theory.
Jean Piaget: assimilation and accommodation
According to Jean Piaget (1896-1980), intellectual development takes place through two processes:
- Assimilation: fitting a new experience into an existing mental framework (schema). Example: a child who knows mangoes sees a new variety of mango and correctly recognises it as a mango.
- Accommodation: changing the schema itself to fit a new experience. Example: a child who has known only sweet ripe mangoes tastes a sour raw mango and changes the idea to "mangoes can also be sour".
- Both involve collecting, storing and organising information and retrieving it for the right stimulus. Loss of sight affects this whole information process.
Piaget's stages and the blind child
| Stage | Age | Effect on the blind child |
|---|---|---|
| Sensorimotor stage | 0-2 years | Blindness causes clear delays in this stage - in reaching for objects, object permanence and moving about; Stephens (1972) pointed out that most of a normal infant's interaction with the surroundings depends on sight |
| Preconceptual stage | 2-4 years | Mental images depend on sensory information; unless parents and teachers make a special effort, that information is low, so he passes this stage late |
| Intuitive stage | 4-7 years | Thinking depends on "here and now" experiences; a sighted child sees printed letters and two-dimensional pictures, while the blind child lives in a three-dimensional world (reading Braille is also a three-dimensional activity); most experience reaches him through words |
| Concrete operational stage | 7-11 years | Reasoning with concrete objects; if experiences are limited, reasoning is also affected - this is due to limited experience, not to blindness |
| Formal (abstract) operational stage | Above 11 years | Problems are imagined and solved in the mind without objects; blind children too can form mental images at about the same age and just as well (though their nature is somewhat different) |
(The preconceptual and intuitive stages together are usually called the "preoperational stage".)
6 sub-stages of the sensorimotor stage:
| Sub-stage | Age | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Reflexes | Birth - 1 month | Behaviour is only reflexes; learns that some objects can be sucked and some cannot |
| Primary circular reactions | 1-4 months | Repeats actions that interest and satisfy him again and again; these are mostly on his own body |
| Secondary circular reactions | 4-8 months | Actions that produce interesting results in the outside world; attention to the outside world begins |
| Coordination of secondary reactions | 8-12 months | Intention begins; uses a means to reach a goal |
| Tertiary circular reactions | 12-18 months | Active experiments on the world by trial and error |
| Internalisation of thought | 18-24 months | Thinking in the mind begins |
- In this stage intelligence shows through movement, without symbols. Knowledge of the world depends on physical experiences. Object permanence (knowing that an object exists even when it cannot be seen) develops in this stage. Towards the end of the stage some symbolic (language) abilities appear.
- Key principle: a child with visual impairment may reach a stage late, but cannot skip it. Even if there is some delay in development, the quality of mental ability does not change because of visual impairment. That is why the intelligence of people with visual impairment is generally equal to that of ordinary children.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
In general, ‘intelligence’ of this disabled children is equal to normal children
- (1)Cerebral Palsy
- (2)Intellectual disability
- (3)Down's Syndrome
- (4)Visual impairment
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (4) Visual impairment
The question asks which group of children with disability generally has intelligence equal to that of other children.
Visual impairment is a sensory disability of the eye or the optic nerve; it does not reduce the thinking ability of the brain. So most children with visual impairment have normal intelligence, and with Braille, audio books and computers they can go on to higher studies. So the answer is option (4) Visual impairment.
Intellectual disability, option (2), by definition means below-average intelligence (IQ below 70). Down's syndrome, option (3), is a genetic cause of intellectual disability. In cerebral palsy, option (1), some children have normal intelligence, but because the brain is damaged many also have intellectual disability, so we cannot say their intelligence is generally equal.
Remember: A sensory loss (eye, ear) does not lower intelligence.
Key factors in cognitive development
- Concept formation: concepts are the bricks of thinking. The basic ability needed to form a concept is classification - noticing similarities and ignoring small differences. Blind children have difficulty in exploring objects; so the similarities they notice lead to faults in classification. They need many kinds of experiences to understand generalisation and relationships.
- Verbalism: using long or meaningless words without real experience and without knowing their exact meaning.
- Conservation: being able to judge correctly that a property (amount, weight, substance) does not change even when the shape changes. In blind children, the development of conservation of volume, weight and substance is delayed. But this delay is temporary; as experience grows, they make up for it in daily life.
- Imagery: before doing any task - eating, talking, jumping, running - an image comes to the mind. These are traces of stored experiences and learnt responses. They can be visual, auditory, tactile or kinaesthetic, or combinations of these (visual-motor, auditory-motor, speech-motor). No physical task is possible without them.
- Creativity: in divergent thinking there is no basic difference between blind and sighted children. The only difference - blind children show more verbal fluency; sighted children use more visual imagery.
Building the world and object permanence
- The information a child born with visual impairment receives is disconnected and in pieces. If there is only hearing without visual confirmation, at first only the sound reaches him. Through touch, movement and coordination he identifies an object's position, cause and support.
- At about 12 months of age a blind infant can search for and grab an object on the basis of sound alone. But without visual stimulation he cannot correctly identify colour, pattern, shape, texture and position.
- A child with weak sight has limited ability to coordinate a lot of information at once. So the picture of reality he forms may differ from ours. Since he gets less guidance, the process is harder for him.
- Object permanence needs a stable visual field. A blind child identifies objects only through sound; if there is no sound, the object might as well not exist.
- Cause and effect: a blind person cannot see the results of his actions. So he is not motivated to act, and cannot understand the power his actions have.
- Constancy: understanding an object regardless of its position is hard for a blind student.
- Conservation: to understand weight, size, length and mass, blind children badly need direct experience.
Exam focus: Piaget - assimilation (fitting the new into an existing schema: recognising a mango), accommodation (changing the schema: learning that a mango can also be sour). A blind child may reach a stage late but cannot skip it; the quality of mental ability does not change - intelligence is equal to that of ordinary children. If reasoning falls in the concrete operational stage, the cause is limited experience, not blindness. Verbalism = using words without experience. The delay in conservation is temporary. In creativity, blind children have more verbal fluency. At 12 months he grabs an object on the basis of sound.
Memory code: Piaget's 5 stages "S-P-I-C-F" - "Some Pupils Invent Clever Formulas" (Sensorimotor, Preconceptual, Intuitive, Concrete, Formal), with ages "0-2-4-7-11". The rule for the blind child: "Late is fine, skipping never".