When we plan a curriculum for children with visual impairment, we follow the same principles that we follow for other children. The aim is the same - to help the child learn easily. But because of the loss of sight, some adjustments in the plan and in carrying it out become essential. Some skills that a sighted child picks up naturally must be taught to a blind child in a planned way. That is why an Expanded Core Curriculum (ECC) is needed. It is also called the Plus Curriculum. Along with these, the child also needs special help from the teacher and special equipment.
What is a curriculum?
- Education is compared to a race: the aims of education are the goal, and the curriculum is the track that leads to that goal.
- In the old view, a curriculum meant only mastering certain skills and certain fields of knowledge.
- In the modern view, a curriculum is not only the subjects taught in school. It is the total of the experiences a pupil gains through the classroom, library, laboratory, playground and the relationships between teachers and pupils. In this sense, the whole of school life is the curriculum; it shapes a balanced personality.
- A modern curriculum takes in all the broad areas of individual and group life. Meaningful activities outside school are also part of the curriculum - if they are planned and organised for an educational purpose.
The key ideas hidden in this concept:
- The curriculum lies in the experiences of the children.
- Content does not become curriculum until it becomes part of the child's total experience.
- A school curriculum is an attempt to give guidance in living.
- It is a special learning environment, deliberately arranged to direct the children's interests and abilities towards active participation in the life of the community and the nation.
Functions of the curriculum
Two factors decide the functions of the curriculum:
| Factor | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Social goals | Taking into account the different capacities in community and national life, and the vast possibilities for both good and bad |
| Individual goals | The problems each person faces in living in society |
The curriculum is the means that links the two. Through its experiences, children achieve self-realisation; at the same time they learn to help build a better society and nation.
Why special approaches for children with visual impairment?
- The whole curriculum turns around two things: "opportunity" and "experience". Giving an opportunity does not mean that experience has been gained. Without experience, understanding of oneself and of the world does not form "fully".
- Sight gives a huge amount of information at a single glance. So sighted children learn from experiences "naturally" and "as a whole".
- Children with visual impairment learn information "in bits and pieces"; they need time to join those bits together and form a concept.
| Sighted children | Children with visual impairment |
|---|---|
| Information comes "as a whole" | Information comes "in bits" |
| Natural learning | Mediated learning - with someone's help, in a planned way |
- Berthold Lowenfeld said that blindness reduces the range and variety of experiences, the ability to get about, and control over the environment. These three "objective effects", which stand in the way of independence, are the root reason for the Plus Curriculum / ECC. (The details of these effects are in the chapter "Visual Impairment: Education".)
Curriculum in inclusive / integrated education
- In a regular class, the child with visual impairment is one among many. So his curriculum should be close to, not different from, the curriculum of sighted children.
- These children get most information through touch and hearing. These sensory experiences must be planned so that they get an experience nearly equal to what others get through sight.
- Therefore in inclusive education no special curriculum is needed; what is needed is special methods based on multi-sensory experiences.
- To learn the regular curriculum, the child must have certain skills that are special to blindness. These are what the Plus Curriculum / ECC contains.
- An inclusive programme is part of the regular school, where everyone has the same curriculum. So under no circumstances should the curriculum be changed just for one blind child; that is neither right nor possible. Instead, through modified and special methods, a "near normal" experience, equal to that of sighted children, should be given.
- Understanding between the regular teacher and the resource teacher / special educator makes this approach even more fruitful. Through this special approach, children with visual impairment gain more than they lose.
Regular curriculum - modified experiences: four steps
The regular curriculum has many "visual experiences" and few "non-visual experiences". So it must be analysed and the visual experiences converted into non-visual ones. This is the order of preference in giving an educational experience:
| Step | What we do |
|---|---|
| 1. Duplicate experience | Giving exactly the same experience that is given to the other children - this is the best, but it is not always possible |
| 2. Modify | Changing the content, the method of presentation, the type of material used, or the response expected from the child |
| 3. Substitute | When a suitable modification is not possible, giving another lesson that is as close as possible to the others' lesson |
| 4. Omit | Sometimes leaving out a lesson, especially in the early days |
- Experience shows that as the level of education rises, it becomes easier to produce materials exactly as they are. Most omissions happen in the first year itself.
- Soon omissions become rare, substitutions become fewer, modifications continue to be needed; and above all, duplicate experiences become more and more possible.
- According to studies by Jangira (1986) and Mani (1982), 80-85% of the regular curriculum can be given to children with visual impairment exactly as it is (duplicated). The rest can be given through modified and substitute experiences. In higher classes, omissions are even fewer.
Adjustments in examinations, boards and the classroom
Children with visual impairment can be seen as two main groups:
- Those who must learn only through Braille or recorded study material.
- Low vision children who can read print with magnifying devices and in good diffused light.
In both cases, no major change in the content of the subjects is needed. However:
- Many secondary education boards in India exempt visually impaired candidates from Mathematics and Science in the Class 10 and 12 examinations and let them take music or an extra language instead. That is why many schools teach Mathematics and Science from Class 6 to 8 and stop from Class 9.
- With today's modern devices this is not necessary; a visually impaired student can take the Class 10 and 12 examinations with Mathematics and Science.
- The West Bengal Board of Secondary Education does not give full exemption in any subject. Only for the construction part in Mathematics and the drawing part in Geography and Biology does it give alternative questions carrying the same marks; all the other questions are the same as those for regular students.
- Special equipment is needed to teach Braille, Mathematics, Science and the ECC subjects; Social Studies needs embossed maps.
Points for the teacher to remember in the classroom (in brief):
| Tip | Detail |
|---|---|
| Models instead of pictures | Show models instead of pictures |
| Say aloud what is written on the board | Read aloud everything written on the board and spell it out |
| Assignments | Accept them in Braille or in audio form; if neither is possible, give an oral test |
| Introducing the surroundings | Introduce the classroom and school building little by little, so that a correct picture forms in the mind |
| Buddy system | A classmate takes on duties such as sharing notes, taking the child out when needed and playing together at games time |
| Mobility | Encourage the child to move about the school campus as freely as possible |
| Equipment | Allow the use in class of the equipment needed for all subjects |
| Expectations | Expect the child to do as well as others when given the right environment, equipment and encouragement; blindness should not be an excuse for poor performance |
| Interaction | Encourage everyone in the class to mix with the child without hesitation |
| Discipline | Apply the same discipline as for the others; no special exemptions in matters of discipline |
| Low vision children | Usually no special methods are needed; giving more time to finish the work is enough; if there is a mobility problem, give some visual orientation |
What is the ECC / Plus Curriculum?
- For children with visual impairment, the ECC is not an "extra" load but a set of "compensatory" skills. The skills of the regular curriculum stand on this foundation.
- These are skills special to blindness; a sighted person does not need them.
- Experience shows that children who are strong in the ECC learn the regular curriculum even better. So teaching ECC skills must become an inseparable part of the education of children with visual impairment.
- Children with visual impairment cannot learn incidentally what sighted children learn by watching others. The ECC was designed to fill this gap and to teach concepts and skills through special instruction.
- It is taught in addition to the core curriculum of general education. Students reach the set goals only through both - the regular curriculum + the ECC.
- The need for the ECC begins from birth.
- The term "Expanded Core Curriculum" was popularised in America around 1996 by Phil Hatlen.
Exam focus: Modern curriculum = the total of experiences. Sighted = natural learning (as a whole); visually impaired = mediated learning (in bits). Giving an opportunity is not the same as experience. Four steps: Duplicate → Modify → Substitute → Omit; 80-85% can be given in duplicate; most omissions happen in the first year. In inclusive education, no special curriculum but special methods are needed. Skills special to blindness = Plus Curriculum / ECC (not extra, but compensatory skills).
Memory code: The four steps "D-M-S-O" ("Do My Studies Ourselves") - Duplicate, Modify, Substitute, Omit; the first is the best, the last is the last resort. "80-85 Duplicate": 80-85% of the curriculum can be given as it is. "Sight = Natural, Dark = Mediated".