Looking at the definitions in order of time shows how the way of describing this condition has changed.
AAMD Definition (1983)
- "Significantly sub-average general intellectual functioning existing together with, or resulting in, deficits in adaptive behaviour, and showing up during the developmental period."
- This definition was given under the leadership of Grossman. Here the developmental period means from conception (the foetal stage) up to the 18th birthday, that is, up to the end of adolescence.
- "Significantly sub-average" means an IQ of 70 or below on a standard intelligence test (for example, Stanford-Binet), that is, 2 standard deviations below the average. In exam options this appears as "IQ below 70".
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
According to the definition of AAMD the developmental period is
- (1)From embryonic stage to the end of adolescent stage.
- (2)From birth to the end of child hood.
- (3)From infancy to the end of puberty.
- (4)From embryonic stage to the end of childhood.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (1) From embryonic stage to the end of adolescent stage.
The question asks what the 'developmental period' means in the AAMD (American Association on Mental Deficiency) definition of mental retardation, now called intellectual disability.
The AAMD definition (Grossman) says mental retardation is significantly sub-average general intellectual functioning existing along with deficits in adaptive behaviour, manifested during the developmental period. The developmental period runs from conception (the embryonic stage) up to 18 years, that is, to the end of adolescence.
So the answer is option (1), from the embryonic stage to the end of the adolescent stage. A fall in intellectual ability caused by an injury after 18 is not called intellectual disability.
Options (2) and (4) stop at the end of childhood and leave out adolescence. Options (2) and (3) start at birth or infancy and leave out prenatal causes. Option (4) is a common trap, but it does not reach 18 years.
Remember: AAMD developmental period = conception to 18 years.
An individual is designated as significantly sub-average when his IQ is below of standford-Binet Test of intelligence.
- (1)IQ below 50
- (2)IQ below 70
- (3)IQ below 90
- (4)IQ below 100
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (2) IQ below 70
The question asks below which IQ a person is called 'significantly sub-average' in intelligence.
On intelligence tests the average IQ is 100. 'Significantly sub-average' means about two standard deviations below the mean. Taking the SD as about 15, the cut-off is 100 − 2 × 15 = 70. So an IQ below 70, together with deficits in adaptive behaviour, falls in the range of intellectual disability.
So the answer is option (2), IQ below 70.
IQ 50, option (1), is near the boundary of the moderate level, not the first cut-off. IQ 90, option (3), is the lower edge of average; people between 70 and 89 are called borderline or slow learners, not intellectually disabled. IQ 100, option (4), is the average itself.
Remember: 100 − 2 × 15 = 70: below this is significantly sub-average.
AAMR Definition (1992)
- Significantly sub-average intellectual functioning together with limitations in at least 2 of the following 10 adaptive skill areas. It shows up before the age of 18.
| 10 adaptive skill areas | |
|---|---|
| 1. Communication | 6. Self-direction |
| 2. Self-care | 7. Health and safety |
| 3. Home living | 8. Functional academics |
| 4. Social skills | 9. Leisure |
| 5. Community use | 10. Work |
- With this definition AAMR brought a big change: instead of the old "mild, moderate, severe, profound" groups, it suggested classifying a person by how much support he needs (details under "Classification").
AAMR Definition (2002)
- "A disability with significant limitations both in intellectual functioning and in adaptive behaviour as expressed in conceptual, social and practical adaptive skills; it begins before the age of 18."
- This is a functional model: the context in which the person lives, the environment, and the interaction between the person and the environment (the ecological view) are all part of it.
- Individually planned supports improve functioning. The outcomes of this interaction are seen in independence, relationships, contribution to society, participation in school and community, and personal well-being.
AAIDD Definition (2010)
- "A disability characterised by significant limitations both in intellectual functioning and in adaptive behaviour, which covers many everyday social and practical skills. It begins before the age of 18."
AAIDD Definition (2021)
- The 12th edition of AAIDD, published in 2021, keeps the same three elements: significant limitations in intellectual functioning and in adaptive behaviour (conceptual, social and practical), with onset during the developmental period.
- There is only one change: the developmental period was fixed as up to the 22nd birthday. This rests on research showing that brain development continues into the twenties.
DSM-5 (2013) / DSM-5-TR (2022)
- DSM-5, the manual of the American Psychiatric Association, places it among the neurodevelopmental disorders. In DSM-5-TR the name is "Intellectual Developmental Disorder (Intellectual Disability)".
- All 3 criteria must be met for diagnosis:
- Criterion A: Deficits in intellectual functions - reasoning, problem solving, planning, abstract thinking, judgement, academic learning and learning from experience (confirmed by clinical assessment and standardised tests).
- Criterion B: Deficits in adaptive functioning - in the conceptual, social and practical domains; without support, daily activities at home, school, work and in the community are limited.
- Criterion C: Onset of these deficits during the developmental period.
- DSM-5 decides severity by adaptive functioning, not by the IQ score.
ICD-11 (WHO)
- WHO's classification ICD-11 calls it "Disorders of Intellectual Development" (code 6A00).
- On standardised tests, both intellectual functioning and adaptive behaviour must be about 2 or more standard deviations below the average (roughly below the 2.3rd percentile), with onset during the developmental period.
- Levels: mild, moderate, severe and profound (besides provisional and unspecified). Because tests cannot reliably tell severe and profound apart, these two are separated only by differences in adaptive behaviour.
PWD Act 1995 Definition
- "A condition of arrested or incomplete development of the mind of a person, which is specially characterised by sub-normal intelligence." (This Act still used the old term.)
- WHO described it in the same way: because the mind develops incompletely, the skills expected at each developmental stage do not appear; so there are problems in intelligence, cognition, language, motor and social abilities.
RPwD Act 2016 Definition
- "Intellectual disability is a condition characterised by significant limitation both in intellectual functioning (reasoning, learning, problem solving) and in adaptive behaviour, which covers a range of everyday, social and practical skills."
- In this Act, the heading "Intellectual disability" also includes Specific Learning Disabilities and Autism Spectrum Disorder.
- It is one of the 21 specified disabilities. A disability of at least 40% is called a "benchmark disability".
Other definitions asked in exams
| Who | Gist of the definition |
|---|---|
| Benda (1954) | A person who cannot manage his own affairs and needs supervision, attention and care from others |
| Smith and Neisworth | Lack of enough intelligence to live independently in society |
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
Those who are not able to do their own works, those need attention and monitoring by others are called Mental Retardation (Intellectual Disabilities) According to this
- (1)NPE - 1986
- (2)Chandrika - 2002
- (3)Premi - 1988
- (4)Benda - 1954
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (4) Benda - 1954
The question asks who defined intellectual disability as the condition of a person who cannot manage their own work and needs supervision and care from others.
This definition was given by C.E. Benda in 1954. According to Benda, a mentally retarded person is one who is incapable of managing himself and his affairs, and needs supervision, control and care for his own welfare and the welfare of the community. It is a social-competence definition rather than an IQ-based one.
So the answer is option (4), Benda - 1954.
NPE 1986 (1) is a national education policy; it discussed education of the disabled but did not give this definition. Chandrika - 2002 (2) and Premi - 1988 (3) are not the names linked to this definition in standard texts.
Remember: "Needs supervision of others" = Benda (1954).
Benda (1954) defines those who are not able to do activities on their own, needs attention and support of others are said to have
- (1)Visual Impairment
- (2)Multiple Disability
- (3)Hearing Impairment
- (4)Intellectual Disability
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (4) Intellectual Disability
The question asks which disability Benda (1954) described as people who cannot manage their own activities and need the supervision and support of others.
Benda defined a mentally retarded person (today we say a person with intellectual disability) as one who "requires supervision, control and care for his own welfare and the welfare of the community". In intellectual disability, both intelligence and adaptive behaviour, the ability to manage daily tasks independently, are below average.
So the answer is option (4), intellectual disability.
Persons with visual impairment (1) or hearing impairment (3) can live independently with training and aids such as Braille and hearing aids; Benda's definition is not about them. Multiple disability (2) means two or more disabilities together, which is a different definition.
Remember: Benda 1954: needs supervision, control and care = intellectual disability.
“Those who are unable to do their own works, who needs to be supervised, attention of others are required are called as persons with intellectual Disabilities”. – is derived by
- (1)Smith
- (2)Benda
- (3)Louis Pasteur
- (4)Einstein
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (2) Benda
The question asks who defined persons with intellectual disability as those who cannot manage their own work and need the supervision and care of others.
There are many definitions of intellectual disability. C. E. Benda's definition is based on social competence: a mentally retarded person is one who cannot manage himself and his affairs, and who needs supervision, control and care for his own welfare and the welfare of the community. The statement in the question carries this idea.
So the answer is option (2), Benda.
Louis Pasteur (3) was a microbiologist known for vaccines and pasteurisation. Einstein (4) was a physicist. Smith (1) is not linked with this definition.
Remember: Needs supervision and care = Benda's definition.
Mental Retardation (Intellectual Disability) is defined as "lack of intelligence to lead independent life in society" by
- (1)Benda
- (2)Rousseau
- (3)Smith, Neisworth
- (4)Hebar
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (3) Smith, Neisworth
The question asks who defined mental retardation (intellectual disability) as "lack of intelligence to lead independent life in society".
Definitions of intellectual disability fall into two broad kinds. Some focus on measured intelligence (IQ); others focus on social competence, that is, the ability to live independently in society. The definition in this question is of the second kind: it links low intelligence to a lack of independent living.
As per the official key, this definition is credited to Smith and Neisworth, so the answer is option (3). I could not confirm the source of this exact wording independently, so remember it as the key gives it.
Heber is linked with the 1959 and 1961 AAMD definitions, which speak of below-average intellectual functioning together with deficits in adaptive behaviour. Rousseau was a philosopher known for naturalistic education. The key did not accept options (1), (2) or (4).
Remember: As per the key: "lack of intelligence to lead independent life" → Smith, Neisworth.
“Inadequate intellectual functioning for independent functioning in society is called intellectual disability”, defined by
- (1)Smith, Neisworth
- (2)C Benda
- (3)F.M. Hill
- (4)Gallandet
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (1) Smith, Neisworth
The question asks who defined intellectual disability as mental ability that is not enough for a person to function independently in society.
Earlier, intellectual disability was judged only by IQ. Later definitions also stressed adaptive behaviour, that is, how far a person can live independently in society. This definition reflects that idea.
As per the official key, this definition is by Smith and Neisworth, so the answer is option (1).
Gallaudet (4) is known for the education of deaf persons and is not linked to this definition. C. Benda (2) and F.M. Hill (3) are not the answer as per the key.
Remember: Definition based on independent functioning in society = Smith, Neisworth (as per key).
“Lack of Intelligence to live independently in a society is called Mental Retardation” is defined by
- (1)Benda
- (2)Hebar
- (3)Smith, Neisworth
- (4)A.A.M.R
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (3) Smith, Neisworth
The question asks who defined mental retardation (now called intellectual disability) in terms of a person's ability to live independently in society.
Definitions of mental retardation fall into two broad types: those based on IQ and those based on social competence. This definition is of the second type: the inability to live on one's own in society is itself treated as the sign of the condition. As per the official key, this definition is by Smith and Neisworth, so the answer is option (3).
The AAMR definition (4) combines three parts: significantly below-average intellectual functioning, deficits in adaptive behaviour, and onset before age 18. Heber (2) is linked with the early AAMD definitions, which also speak of intellectual functioning together with adaptive behaviour. Benda (1) also stressed social competence, so students can confuse it here; for the exam, remember the key's answer (3).
Remember: Lack of intelligence to live independently in society – Smith and Neisworth (as per key).
Exam focus: AAMD 1983 - developmental period = conception to 18 years; significantly sub-average = IQ 70 or below (exam option: "below 70"). AAMR 1992 - 10 adaptive skill areas, limitation in at least 2, levels of support. AAMR 2002 / AAIDD 2010 - conceptual, social and practical skills, before 18. AAIDD 2021 - before 22. RPwD 2016 - reasoning, learning, problem solving. Benda (1954) - needs supervision by others; Smith and Neisworth - lack of enough intelligence for independent living.
Memory code: Age limits "18 - 18 - 22": 18 for AAMD, AAMR and AAIDD up to 2010, 22 in AAIDD 2021. Definers: "Benda = Backed by supervision, Smith = Self-reliance missing" - Benda: needs others' supervision; Smith and Neisworth: not enough intelligence to live independently.