The charismatic adult
- The teacher has a key role in raising a student's self-esteem. Research on resilience shows that the influence of even one adult matters greatly in helping children with learning and attention problems grow up hopeful and successful.
- Julius Segal called that person a "charismatic adult": an adult with whom children identify and from whom they gather strength.
The positive teacher mindset (5 points)
| No. | The teacher's belief |
|---|---|
| 1 | Every student wants to learn and succeed. If a student does not seem to, we must understand the nature of his learning problem |
| 2 | Quitting, not trying, acting as the class clown or as a bully - these are counterproductive coping strategies that hide weakness, low self-esteem and helplessness. Instead of punishment, we should think about how to reduce their daily frustration |
| 3 | To reduce these strategies, children must be taught in the way they learn best; the teacher must first change his own teaching style and not hesitate to make the needed accommodations |
| 4 | Every child has "islands of competence" (areas of strength). They must be identified, strengthened and displayed. The strength-based model does not deny problems, but uses strengths as a key part of any intervention programme |
| 5 | Students should be actively invited to take part in their own education |
- When this mindset is adopted, strategies to raise self-esteem and hope can be built on attribution theory. Children should develop a sense of ownership, control and responsibility for their successes, and see mistakes not as defeats but as learning experiences.
Clarifying problems and making accommodations
- Clarifying the problem: teachers and parents must accept the nature of the learning problems; help the child understand his strengths and weaknesses; and make suitable accommodations in the school programme. In the evaluation, the child, parents and teachers should be made active "partners"; ask the child himself, "What are your strengths and weaknesses?"
- Accommodations: each child learns in his own way, so he must be taught in that way. These accommodations do not need big changes; nor does each student need a separate plan. The student, teacher and parents must understand the child's strengths and weaknesses and agree on shared goals.
| Accommodation | How it helps |
|---|---|
| Untimed tests | Even a few extra minutes raise marks considerably; time pressure goes and anxiety falls |
| Maximum time for homework | If most of the class does 6 sums in 15 minutes, that is the maximum time; the work of a child who does only 3 in that time should also be accepted. Making a child spend too long harms learning and raises tension at home |
| Clarity about homework | Giving a monthly list of assignments to those who find copying from the blackboard hard; assigning a "buddy" so that the homework is known correctly |
| Use of a computer | Those who find it hard to put ideas on paper do better with a computer; if writing with a pen stays hard however much they try, let them use a computer |
Teaching decision-making and problem-solving
- The basis of high self-esteem and resilience is the belief that one has control over many areas of one's own life. This belief is linked with a sense of ownership, and that is the foundation of motivation.
- So children should get chances to make decisions and solve problems from an early age. Only with choices and decisions do children gain a sense of ownership and become their own advocates.
- Ways of giving choices:
- The teachers of one school told students, "Look at these 6 sums and do the 4 you think will teach you best." Even though this was a choice to "do less", the sense of ownership made students do more homework than before.
- When there is difficulty in learning, ask the children themselves what helps and try those strategies. Myrna Shure, in the "I Can Problem Solve" programme, found that even young children can think of different choices for learning.
Helping children contribute and reducing the fear of mistakes
- Self-esteem and resilience grow when children get the chance to contribute to their world and to the welfare of others. When adults were asked, "What memory from school raised your self-esteem?", most said "being asked to help".
- Students who feel they are making a positive difference at school are more motivated to study well. Not a single student should feel that he is not contributing at school.
- Examples: students with learning problems reading to younger children; organising a sale to help a poor family (the academic skills in it raised their self-esteem); caring for plants at school, painting murals and displaying favourite pictures; helping one another in cooperative learning groups.
- Fear of mistakes: all students fear making mistakes and being laughed at. Those with learning problems face more failures, so they fear even more; their problems show clearly at school, so they feel "exposed".
- This fear should be discussed directly before any mistakes happen, in the introductory period at the start of the school year. Ask, "Who thinks they will make a mistake this year?", and let the teacher raise his own hand first and tell how the fear of mistakes blocked his learning as a student. Then discuss with the class what can be done to reduce the fear and set rules on how to respond when one does not know the answer.
- Discussing the fear openly reduces its power. Combined with a discussion that everyone learns differently and that everyone has strengths (islands of competence) and weaknesses, it creates a classroom full of respect and understanding.
- Being a "charismatic adult" in children's lives, so that they gather strength from us, is the greatest gift a teacher can give.
Exam focus: "Charismatic adult" = Julius Segal. "Islands of competence" = areas of strength; strength-based model. "I Can Problem Solve" = Myrna Shure. Acting as a clown or a bully = counterproductive coping strategies; understand, do not punish. Accommodations: untimed tests, maximum time for homework, computer. Adults' best school memory = being asked to help. Discuss the fear of mistakes at the start of the school year.
Memory code: "Segal - Strength-giver, Shure - Solve": Segal = charismatic adult who gives strength; Shure = "I Can Problem Solve". The teacher's strategies "C-A-D-C-F" ("Caring Adults Develop Confident Futures"): Clarifying the problem, Accommodations, teaching Decisions, chance to Contribute, reducing Fear of mistakes.