To give children with visual impairment the right educational plan, to increase their abilities and knowledge, and to make up for the lack of sight with the other senses, their learning needs must be assessed.
The problem with psychological tests
- In standard tests, many questions depend on visual information. So the test result depends not only on the child's ability but also on the nature of the test.
- Merely converting written tests into large print, audio form or a computer CD did not make them successful.
- The test must be given in the form the student is used to. For example, a student who has learnt only uncontracted Braille must not be given a test in contracted Braille. A student who has never taken an audio test must not suddenly be given one; he or she must be made familiar with it beforehand.
- Screen reader and screen magnification software may be used. A very complex item may be simplified or left out, but the scoring method must not be changed; the content of the test must also not change much.
- Blind students are usually not part of the population on which a test is standardised. So the test must be adapted and the results interpreted carefully.
Rules to follow while testing
To measure behaviour and intelligence accurately, these rules must be followed:
- A room with good, suitable lighting.
- Giving some time before the test to create a familiar, comfortable atmosphere.
- Setting aside time to explain the test materials; letting the student touch and understand the materials before the test begins.
- Giving printed material in large print suited to their sight; felt-tip pens for writing.
- If the questions are in Braille, the examiner must first check the student's Braille reading ability.
- An audio tape or a person who reads aloud (reader) for oral tests.
- For blind students, true/false questions are better than multiple-choice questions.
- When testing through the Braille medium, speed tests and timed tests are not suitable.
- Give a break if the student gets tired.
Intelligence and personality tests
Intelligence is abstract and cannot be seen; it is known only through mental activities. The first intelligence test was designed by Alfred Binet. Later, special tests also came for the blind, measuring verbal intelligence, performance intelligence, educational abilities and emotional adjustment.
| Test | Key point |
|---|---|
| Interim Hayes-Binet Intelligence Test | 1942; for the blind above 6 years |
| Perkins-Binet Test | 1980; intelligence of blind children |
| WISC (Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children) | Only the verbal part is used for the blind |
| Indian adaptation of WISC-R | To measure the verbal intelligence of Indian blind people reliably; a 6 × 3 × 2 design (6 age groups, 3 education groups, 2 gender groups), 20 people in each cell; 5 language-related subtests |
| Vithoba Paknikar Performance Test | An Indian performance test for the intelligence of the blind |
| BLAT (Blind Learning Aptitude Test) | Braille-like raised-line symbols; telling the differences between symbols is the main element |
| Haptic Intelligence Scale | Intelligence of blind adults |
| EPQ (Eysenck Personality Questionnaire) | Hans Eysenck, Sybil Eysenck; personality traits |
| Personality questionnaire for students with visual impairment | Tej Bahadur Singh; on 296 people (181 males, 115 females) |
The Indian WISC-R study - findings:
- Blind women scored lower in the similarities and vocabulary subtests; that means in our country gender is also an influencing factor. Age also affects the score.
- In our country blind children join school later than ordinary children; this further harms language development.
- Those with low vision learn something from their surroundings, so they develop more than the totally blind.
- Age, education, gender and the severity of visual impairment - these four affect the scores.
About BLAT: it was designed for children of all classes. Items were adapted from the Culture Fair Intelligence Test and Raven's Progressive Matrices. It was normed in the 1960s on students of residential schools; those norms are thought to show higher scores. Although there are some difficulties with the materials and shapes, it is useful for knowing the student's strengths and weaknesses and for getting qualitative information by observing performance.
About EPQ: before it, the Eysenck Personality Inventory (EPI) was used. According to Eysenck's theory, the foundation of personality is the temperament that comes through genes before birth; later, learning shapes it.
Tej Bahadur Singh's questionnaire: two forms were made for assessing the personality of people with visual impairment, for Hindi-speaking and English-speaking students. The English items were turned into simple Hindi and reviewed by a 6-member mental health committee; the split-half method was used for reliability.
Concept development: understanding the features of objects and their spatial relationship with other objects is concept development. In blind children it happens slowly, because they lack the chances to learn incidentally by seeing. That is why the assessment must look at it, and experiences of learning by touching and hearing real objects must be given. (The effect of visual impairment on development is in the chapter "Visual Impairment: Educational Implications and Teaching".)
Learning media assessment (LMA)
- To mix in society, four skills are needed: listening, speaking, reading and writing; among these, reading and writing are equally important.
- LMA is an assessment done to record the sensory channels through which the student gathers information and to choose the literacy medium that suits him or her. The opinion of all team members is taken.
- Based on it, it is decided which students are suited to a print literacy programme and which to a Braille literacy programme. The final decision on Braille teaching and the reading medium is taken by the IEP team, keeping the child's future needs in mind.
- Later it is reported whether the student is learning to read and write well in that medium.
Principles for choosing the medium:
- Ordinary people use print; children with low vision use large print or Braille according to their ability.
- The teacher must know the needs and abilities of children with low vision. Each one's sight is unique (some have central vision, some side vision), so one medium cannot be decided for all.
- Those who gather information through sight must be taught print; those whose sight is not enough for print gather information through other channels.
- Some can use both print and Braille; some may not need large print; sometimes Braille must be given priority.
- Some use print by day and Braille by night; some can read print but cannot write it - they use both methods.
- The choice of medium depends on the ability to gather information through the other senses; not merely on visual acuity, legal blindness or someone's opinion.
- The teachers who decide the medium must be trained.
The student portfolio
- The reports of the various tests done on the student, together with the plan of suggestions written by the teachers, make up the student portfolio.
- It contains the results and recommendations based on how the student cooperates while doing tasks with peers, the family and others.
- The main aim of assessment: to find out how far the student's skills affect his or her learning.
The teacher's main tasks in assessment:
- Using the child's current IEP / IFSP and the information from meetings with parents, other teachers and related-service professionals; informing the student of all the assessment results.
- Writing the present level of performance in the IEP, and goals based on evaluation criteria.
- Formal and informal pre-tests to know the present level; then lesson plans for any area such as Braille; a follow-up test to know the progress towards the IEP goals.
- Functional vision assessment over many sessions: examining eye and medical records, use of optical devices and special equipment, recommending adjustments.
The assessment process: 8 steps
| Step | What is done |
|---|---|
| 1 | As soon as a vision problem is suspected, examining the parents' information and medical records; explaining their rights to the parents |
| 2 | If there are no medical records, getting an eye doctor's examination done through the parents; the doctor completes the examination and sends the eye report to the school |
| 3 | Examining the eye report and seeing whether the student meets the eligibility criteria |
| 4 | If the criteria are not met, recording this, and the parents and school management closing the process |
| 5 | If the criteria are met, doing the functional vision assessment |
| 6 | Meeting the parents through the IEP to collect information and explaining the assessment methods |
| 7 | Taking information from parents and teachers and doing the educational, vision and media assessments |
| 8 | Holding an IEP team meeting and deciding the student's eligibility and need for special education services |
The functional vision report
The report the teacher writes at the end of the assessment contains:
- The student's identifying information, educational history, a summary of school records
- Medicines, medical information; the eye condition from the eye doctor's report in simple terms
- Low vision clinical evaluation; information from interviews
- Functional vision results; educational performance in reading, writing and mathematics
- Eligibility, services needed, guidance
- Present level in the areas of the Expanded Core Curriculum (ECC)
- Recommendations
(ECC areas, Braille and devices are in the chapter "Visual Impairment: Expanded Core Curriculum, Braille, O&M and Assistive Technology"; details of preparing an IEP are in the chapter "Learning Disability: Curriculum Adaptation, IEP and Interventions".)
Exam focus: Hayes-Binet - 1942, for the blind above 6 years; Perkins-Binet - 1980; for the blind, the verbal part of WISC; Indian adaptation of WISC-R 6 × 3 × 2; Vithoba Paknikar - Indian performance test; BLAT - raised-line symbols; EPQ - Hans and Sybil Eysenck. For blind students true/false questions are better; speed tests are not suitable in Braille; felt-tip pen for writing. LMA - choice of print / large print / Braille; not on acuity alone.
Memory code: Intelligence tests "Hayes 42, Perkins 80" - Hayes-Binet 1942, Perkins-Binet 1980. WISC-R design "6 ages × 3 education levels × 2 genders". Assessment path "Records - Doctor - Eligibility - FVA - IEP". Medium rule "Medium = not a measure of sight, but the channel of information".