Educational assessment is essential for identifying a learning disability. Educational assessment does not mean just giving a test; it is a process with many sides. Assessment is the process of collecting information in order to make decisions about students.
Testing, Measurement, Assessment and Evaluation
- These four words are often used in place of one another; there are small differences between them. We use them according to the purpose.
- Testing: giving a set of questions or tasks (a test) under set conditions to get a sample of the student's performance.
- Measurement: expressing a student's needs and abilities in numbers.
- Assessment: collecting information through various methods and finding out strengths and limitations according to the present level.
- Evaluation: judging the value of the information collected, in order to decide about the student's progress or the programme.
- Both assessment and evaluation depend on the processes of testing and measurement.
Purposes of Assessment
McLoughlin and Lewis (1994) gave 5 basic purposes of educational assessment:
| Purpose | What we do |
|---|---|
| 1. Screening | Identifying early the students who are likely to have learning difficulties |
| 2. Determining eligibility | Collecting the information professionals need to identify that a student has a learning disability |
| 3. Programme planning | Planning placement and specific interventions; preparing the Individualised Education Programme (IEP) |
| 4. Monitoring progress | Watching the student's progress by collecting information regularly |
| 5. Programme evaluation | Judging every year how well the programme has worked |
From Screening to Full Assessment
- Screening is a quick check done for everyone. Only children whom screening shows may have a problem get a full, in-depth assessment. Order: first the checklist and screening → then the full assessment.
- Screening checklists usually cover problems in these areas: visual and auditory perception, attention, reading, memory, writing and mathematics.
- A checklist helps to find the child's real, difficult problem and to decide which method to use to study it in detail.
- Example: we expect an eight-year-old to be in Class 3. If, in spite of good teaching and a good environment, his performance in one or more subjects is at Class 1 level or lower, he needs learning support.
The Discrepancy Model
- According to the discrepancy model, there is a significant discrepancy between the academic performance of students with LD and their intelligence (IQ).
- The child does not achieve adequately for his age, or the approved grade-level standards, in one or more of these areas:
- Oral expression
- Listening comprehension
- Written expression
- Basic reading skills
- Reading comprehension
- Mathematical calculation
- Mathematical problem solving
- Or the child does not make enough progress to meet those standards.
- Limitation: we have to wait until the child falls far behind (the "wait to fail" criticism).
Response to Intervention (RTI) Model
- As an alternative to the discrepancy model, Response to Intervention (RTI) began to be used as an identification model after IDEA 2004.
- Here good-quality teaching is given to everyone, and it is measured regularly who is not making the expected progress. Children who do not respond even to good teaching and extra support are sent for a full assessment for LD.
- In RTI, teaching increases in tiers (whole class → small group → intensive individual support); details of these teaching tiers are in the chapter "Learning Disability: Intervention".
Early Identification: Fluency Measures
- Fluency measures in reading are very useful for identifying at-risk readers in the primary classes themselves.
- Depending on age, the child is asked to read letters, real words or nonsense (made-up) words without context, or a grade-appropriate text.
- These measures are timed; the score = the number of letters or words read correctly in one minute.
- Because this is oral reading, each child must be tested individually; even so, they are easy, take only a few minutes, need only a little training for teachers, and predict risk well in advance.
- With early identification and suitable support, the backlog that builds up in higher classes can be prevented.
Identification Methods and Fair Assessment
- Methods used to identify a learning disability: medical examination (to rule out visual, hearing and neurological causes), study of the family, school and surroundings, behavioural assessment, and educational tests. Adaptations are not a method of identification; they are changes made in teaching after identification.
- In the USA, PL 94-142 (November 1975) laid down that every student with a disability must get free and appropriate public education, and that the assessment for it must be done without discrimination and without bias. It set out procedures to protect against wrong assessment and wrong placement.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
According to Samuel Kirk these methods are not used for identifying children with learning disabilities
- (1)Medical Test
- (2)Study of family, school and environment
- (3)Behaviour Assessment
- (4)Adaptations
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (4) Adaptations
The question asks which method is not used, according to Samuel Kirk, to identify children with learning disabilities.
Identification means finding out whether a problem exists and what kind it is. For this we use a medical test (to rule out vision, hearing or neurological causes), a study of the family, school and environment (to know the child's background), and behaviour assessment (classroom observation and testing). Adaptations are the changes made in teaching and curriculum after the child has been identified.
Adaptations are a teaching step that follows identification, not a way to identify. So the answer is option (4).
Medical tests, the study of family, school and environment, and behaviour assessment are all identification methods, so options (1), (2) and (3) are not the answer.
Remember: Identify first (tests, study, assessment); adapt afterwards.
Exam focus: 5 purposes of assessment (McLoughlin and Lewis 1994): screening, eligibility, planning, monitoring, evaluation. Screening first, full assessment afterwards. Discrepancy model = significant gap between IQ and achievement; 7 areas. RTI = identification based on response to teaching. Fluency measure = words read correctly in a minute; each child tested individually. Adaptations are not an identification method.
Memory code: 5 purposes SEPME ("Some Exams Prepare Minds Early") - Screening, Eligibility, Programme planning, Monitoring progress, Evaluation of the programme. Discrepancy model = "IQ high, marks low"; RTI = "Teach, measure, watch the response".