These three words are often used together, but the exam asks about the difference.
Accommodation
- A change in how the learner learns and how the learner shows what was learnt. What has to be learnt does not change.
- Accommodations help the learner "work around" the learning difficulty.
- Examples: extra time in examinations, reading out the test questions, large print, writing on a computer instead of paper and pencil, a scribe.
- The standards and the curriculum stay the same for everyone.
Modification
- A change in what the learner learns and how much, that is, in the expected outcomes themselves.
- Examples: 5 spelling words instead of the 20 given each week; locating only the states and not the state capitals; the same content made less complex.
- Standards and quantity are reduced, so this is a big decision.
Adaptation
- All the changes a regular teacher makes in the lesson plan for children with special needs in an inclusive class are together called adaptation.
- It is the broad term: both accommodation and modification come under it.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
The changes made by regular teacher in his lesson plan for children with special needs in inclusive classroom. It is called
- (1)Acceleration
- (2)Accomodation
- (3)Appreciation
- (4)Adaptation
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (4) Adaptation
The question asks the name for the changes a regular teacher makes in the lesson plan for children with special needs in an inclusive class.
Adaptation means modifying the content, teaching method, TLM, activities and evaluation to suit the child's needs, for example a raised model instead of a picture for a child with visual impairment, or breaking a lesson into small steps for a child with intellectual disability. Such changes in the lesson plan are called curriculum adaptation. So the answer is option (4) Adaptation.
Many students choose (2) Accommodation. Accommodation means access changes that do not alter the content, such as extra time, a front seat or a scribe; the broader term for changes in the lesson plan itself is adaptation. Acceleration is moving gifted children ahead faster, and appreciation is only encouragement. So (1), (2) and (3) are wrong.
Remember: Changes in the lesson plan for CWSN = adaptation.
| Point | Accommodation | Modification |
|---|---|---|
| What changes | How the learner learns / shows learning | What the learner learns / how much |
| Standards | Same for everyone | Reduced or changed |
| Curriculum | Same | Adapted / reduced |
| Example | Extra time, reading aloud, large print | 5 spelling words instead of 20 |
Legal basis
- RPwD Act 2016, Section 2(y), defines reasonable accommodation: necessary and appropriate modification and adjustments, without imposing a disproportionate or undue burden, so that a person with disability can enjoy or exercise rights equally with others.
- Section 17(i): make suitable modifications in the curriculum and the examination system to meet the needs of students with disabilities. Examples: extra time to complete the examination paper, the facility of a scribe, exemption from second and third language courses.
- The US law IDEA also strongly and repeatedly supports accommodation. A child must not be removed from the regular class just because the child needs changes in the curriculum. If the child is taken out of the regular class for any part of the day, the IEP team has to write the reason for it in the IEP.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
According to RPWD Act 2016, this section states that to make suitable modifications in the curriculum and examination system to meet the needs of students with disabilities such as extra time for completion of examination paper, facility of scribe or amanuensis, exemption from second and third language courses.
- (1)8 (1)
- (2)12 (1)
- (3)19 (2) D
- (4)17 (I)
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (4) 17 (I)
The question asks which section of the RPwD Act 2016 provides for changes in the curriculum and examinations, such as extra time, a scribe and exemption from second and third languages.
Chapter III of the RPwD Act deals with education. Section 16 states the duty of educational institutions to provide inclusive education. Section 17 lists the specific measures the government shall take to promote inclusive education, and its clause (i) is to make suitable modifications in the curriculum and examination system, such as extra time, a scribe or amanuensis and exemption from second and third language courses.
The wording in the question is clause (i) of Section 17, so the answer is option (4).
Section 8 deals with protection and safety of persons with disabilities in situations of risk and disasters, Section 12 with access to justice, and Section 19 with vocational training and self-employment. None of them deals with examination concessions.
Remember: RPwD 17 (i) = exam concessions: extra time, scribe, language exemption.
5 types of curriculum adaptation (from the easiest to the biggest change)
These five types overlap to some extent. The change grows as you go down the list; move down only when needed.
| Type | What it is | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Curriculum as it is | Always check whether the IEP learner can benefit from the general curriculum itself; incidental learning takes place. This is the type most often forgotten | The standard curriculum outcomes themselves |
| 2. Same activity, different goal | The learner takes part in the same activity with everyone, but the goal is different. The principle of partial participation applies here | A learner with poor attention staying on task for 5 minutes; sharing in a discussion by pressing a switch on a communication device; drawing a picture instead of writing to express ideas; holding the book during reading time; understanding the effect of the Second World War on the present instead of the names and dates of battles |
| 3. Material / environmental adaptation | Changing the materials or the environment so that the learner can take part in the general curriculum | 5 spelling words instead of 20; cooking with picture instructions instead of written ones; from a large group to small groups; from lecture to cooperative learning; writing on a computer; reading the test aloud; highlighting key concepts in the textbook; listening to a recorded textbook; large print; an assistive technology device; visual cues such as a picture / word timetable; a notes guide with the key concepts of a lecture |
| 4. Physical assistance | Help from another person. Where possible, the natural support of classmates is better - they are always around. Otherwise a support teacher, an assistant, the class teacher or a parent volunteer. The helpers need training | Switching on the computer for the learner; guiding the hand in handwriting; helping to press a switch; completing most steps of an activity and having the learner do the rest; pushing the wheelchair to the next activity |
| 5. Alternative / substitute curriculum | Also called a functional curriculum; it teaches "life skills". It is a big change and must be written in the IEP; decide only after weighing the gains and losses. It may or may not take place in the regular class | Community-based instruction (useful for everyone); job skills in the school canteen; using a communication device; washing the sports department's clothes; cooking / cleaning skills at home |
Exam focus: Accommodation = the "how" changes (extra time, reading aloud); modification = the "what / how much" changes (fewer words, fewer goals). The change a teacher makes in the lesson plan in an inclusive class = adaptation. RPwD 2016: reasonable accommodation - Section 2(y); changes in curriculum and examinations - Section 17(i). Of the five types, the one most often forgotten is "curriculum as it is"; the biggest change is the "alternative curriculum".
Memory code: "Accommodation = HOW, Modification = WHAT" (A-H, M-W). The five types are "S-D-M-P-A" ("Some Days My Plans Alter") - Same curriculum as it is, Different goal, Materials / environment, Physical assistance, Alternative curriculum (the change gets bigger as you go down). RPwD: "2(y) for accommodation, 17(i) for exams".